Application Note | Tablet Roughness

Pharmaceutical Tablets: Roughness Inspection with an Optical Profiler

Coated vs Uncoated Tablets Compared by ISO 25178 Roughness in Seconds

Assorted tablets and capsules on a white surface

Research & Experimental Testing

Jocelyn Esparza

Visual Design & Editorial

Andrew Shore

Introduction

Pharmaceutical tablets are the most popular medicinal dosage used today. Each tablet is made up of a combination of active substances (the chemicals that produce the pharmacological effect) and inactive substances (disintegrant, binder, lubricant, diluent, usually in powder form). The active and inactive substances are compressed or molded into a solid. Then, depending on the manufacturer’s specifications, the tablets are either coated or uncoated.

Importance of Tablet Coatings and Surface Finish

To be effective, tablet coatings need to follow the fine contours of embossed logos or characters on tablets, they need to be stable and sturdy enough to survive handling of the tablet, and they must not cause the tablets to stick to each other during the coating process. Current tablets typically have a polysaccharide and polymer-based coating that includes substances like pigments and plasticizers. The two most common types of tablet coatings are film coatings and sugar coatings. Compared to sugar coatings, film coatings are less bulky, more durable and less time-consuming to prepare and apply; however, they have more difficulty hiding the tablet’s appearance. Tablet coatings are essential for moisture protection, masking the taste of the ingredients and making tablets easier to swallow. More importantly, the coating controls the location and the rate at which the drug is released.

ℹ️ Learn more about surface profiling lab services.

Measurement Objective

In this application, we use the NANOVEA profilometer and advanced Mountains software to measure and quantify the topography of various name-brand pressed pills (one coated and two uncoated) to compare their surface roughness. It is assumed that Advil (coated) will have the lowest surface roughness due to its protective coating.

NANOVEA ST500 Large Area

Optical 3D Profilometer

NANOVEA ST500 large area optical profilometer for non-contact 3D surface measurement

Test Conditions

Three batches of name-brand pharmaceutical pressed tablets were scanned with the NANOVEA HS2000 using a high-speed line sensor to measure various surface roughness parameters according to ISO 25178. Each scan covered an area of 2 × 2 mm at a lateral scan resolution of 5 × 5 µm, with a scan time of 4 s.

Six pink coated Advil tablets, six white Tylenol caplets and six white Excedrin caplets on black backgrounds
Fig. 1: The samples: Advil, Tylenol and Excedrin.

Results and Discussion

ISO 25178 Surface Height Parameters

After scanning the tablets, a surface roughness study was conducted with the advanced Mountains analysis software to calculate the arithmetic mean height, root-mean-square height and maximum height of each tablet. The calculated values support the assumption that Advil has a lower surface roughness due to the protective coating encasing its ingredients. Tylenol has the highest surface roughness of the three tablets measured.

Advil
ISO 25178 parameterTablet 1Tablet 2Tablet 3Tablet 4Tablet 5AverageStd dev
Sq (µm)1.2201.4061.0451.7660.98851.2850.315
Sz (µm)9.96412.179.86637.8213.7316.7111.91
Sa (µm)0.97061.1170.83021.1090.76520.9580.159

Table 1: Surface height parameters of five Advil tablets.

Tylenol
ISO 25178 parameterTablet 1Tablet 2Tablet 3Tablet 4Tablet 5AverageStd dev
Sq (µm)6.8136.2245.5415.7853.0495.4821.444
Sz (µm)70.7253.6250.2447.4330.7950.5614.29
Sa (µm)5.1304.7683.9174.4042.4074.1251.060

Table 2: Surface height parameters of five Tylenol tablets.

Excedrin
ISO 25178 parameterTablet 1Tablet 2Tablet 3Tablet 4Tablet 5AverageStd dev
Sq (µm)4.1194.5423.4893.4622.8513.6930.653
Sz (µm)62.1057.4841.2040.1031.4946.4712.828
Sa (µm)3.0323.1732.7262.6772.1322.7480.402

Table 3: Surface height parameters of five Excedrin tablets.

2D and 3D False Color View of the Samples

A 2D and 3D height map of each tablet’s surface topography shows the height distributions measured. One of the five tablets was selected to represent each brand. These height maps are a great tool for visual detection of outlying surface features such as pits or peaks.

3D views and 2D height maps of a 2 mm square on an Advil, a Tylenol and an Excedrin tablet
Fig. 2: 2D and 3D false color views of Advil, Tylenol and Excedrin.

Conclusion

In this study, we analyzed and compared the surface roughness of three name-brand pressed pharmaceutical pills: Advil, Tylenol and Excedrin. Advil proved to have the lowest average surface roughness, which can be attributed to the orange coating encasing the drug. In contrast, Excedrin and Tylenol both lack coatings, yet their surface roughness still differs. Tylenol proved to have the highest average surface roughness of all the tablets studied.

Using the NANOVEA HS2000 with a high-speed line sensor, we were able to measure five tablets in less than one minute, which can prove useful for quality control testing of hundreds of pills in production.

Frequently Asked Questions About Tablet Roughness

Why measure tablet surface roughness?

Coatings must follow embossed logos, survive handling and not stick during coating, while protecting from moisture, masking taste and controlling where and how fast the drug is released; roughness is a direct check on the coating and the pressed surface.

How were the tablets measured?

Five tablets each of Advil, Tylenol and Excedrin were scanned over 2 × 2 mm at 5 × 5 µm lateral resolution with a high-speed line sensor, about 4 s per scan, and analyzed to ISO 25178.

Which tablet was smoothest?

Coated Advil, with an average Sa of 0.958 µm and Sq of 1.285 µm.

Which was roughest?

Uncoated Tylenol, with an average Sa of 4.125 µm and Sq of 5.482 µm; uncoated Excedrin averaged Sa 2.748 µm.

How consistent were the tablets?

Standard deviations over five tablets show the batch variation; for Advil, Sa varied by 0.159 µm and Sz by 11.91 µm, with one tablet reaching Sz 37.82 µm.

Is it fast enough for production QC?

Five tablets were measured in less than a minute, which suits quality control of large numbers of tablets.

Need to Inspect Tablet Surfaces?