Application Note | Scratch Hardness Testing

Scratch Hardness Measurement of Metals per ASTM G171 Using a Mechanical Tester

Comparing the Scratch Hardness Number (HSp) of Copper, Aluminum, and Stainless Steel

Rows of steel coils in a metal processing plant

Research & Experimental Testing

Duanjie Li

Visual Design & Editorial

Andrew Shore

Introduction

In general, hardness tests measure the resistance of materials to permanent or plastic deformation. There are three types of hardness measurements: scratch hardness, indentation hardness and rebound hardness. A scratch hardness test measures a material’s resistance to scratch and abrasion due to friction from a sharp object. It was originally developed by German mineralogist Friedrich Mohs in 1820 and is still widely used to rank the physical properties of minerals. This test method is also applicable to metals, ceramics, polymers, and coated surfaces.

How a Scratch Hardness Test Works

During a scratch hardness measurement, a diamond stylus of specified geometry scratches into a material’s surface along a linear path under a constant normal force with a constant speed. The average width of the scratch is measured and used to calculate the scratch hardness number (HSP). This technique provides a simple solution for scaling the hardness of different materials.

Measurement Objective

In this study, the NANOVEA PB1000 Mechanical Tester is used to measure the scratch hardness of different metals in compliance with ASTM G171-03.

Simultaneously, this study showcases the capacity of the NANOVEA Mechanical Tester in performing scratch hardness measurement with high precision and reproducibility.

NANOVEA PB1000 Large Platform

Mechanical Tester

Nanoindenter and scratch tester platform NANOVEA PB1000 with nano and micro modules

Test Conditions

The NANOVEA PB1000 Mechanical Tester performed scratch hardness tests on three polished metals (Cu110, Al6061 and SS304). A conical diamond stylus of apex angle 120° with tip radius of 200 µm was used. Each sample was scratched three times with the same test parameters to ensure reproducibility of the results. The test parameters are summarized below. A profile scan at a low normal load of 10 mN was performed before and after the scratch test to measure the change in the surface profile of the scratch.

ParameterValue
Normal force10 N
Temperature24°C (RT)
Sliding speed20 mm/min
Sliding distance10 mm
AtmosphereAir
StylusConical diamond, 120° apex angle, 200 µm tip radius
Pre- and post-scan load10 mN

Scratch hardness test parameters.

Conical diamond stylus of the NANOVEA PB1000 above a polished metal sample
Scratch hardness test setup with the conical diamond stylus.

Results and Discussion

The images of the scratch tracks of three metals (Cu110, Al6061 and SS304) after the tests are shown in Fig. 1 in order to compare the scratch hardness of different materials. The mapping function of the NANOVEA Mechanical Software was used to create three parallel scratches tested under the same condition in an automated protocol. The measured scratch track width and calculated scratch hardness number (HSP) are summarized and compared in Table 1. The metals show different wear track widths of 174, 220 and 89 µm for Al6061, Cu110 and SS304, respectively, resulting in a calculated HSP of 0.84, 0.52 and 3.2 GPa.

Microscope image of the scratch track on Al6061 at 100x, with the track width marked
Al6061
Microscope image of the scratch track on Cu110 at 100x, with the track width marked
Cu110
Microscope image of the narrower scratch track on SS304 at 100x, with the track width marked
SS304

Fig. 1: Microscope images of the scratch tracks post test (100x magnification).

MetalScratch track width (µm)HSp (GPa)
Al6061174 ± 110.84
Cu110220 ± 10.52
SS30489 ± 53.20

Table 1: Summary of scratch track width and scratch hardness number.

In addition to the scratch hardness computed from the scratch track width, the evolution of coefficient of friction (COF), true depth and acoustic emission were recorded in situ during the scratch hardness test. Here, the true depth is the depth difference between the penetration depth of the stylus during the scratch test and the surface profile measured in the pre-scan. The COF, true depth and acoustic emission of Cu110 are shown in Fig. 2 as an example. Such information provides insight into mechanical failures taking place during scratching, enabling users to detect mechanical defects and further investigate the scratch behavior of the tested material.

Coefficient of friction, true depth and acoustic emission along the 10 mm scratch on Cu110
Fig. 2: The evolution of coefficient of friction, true depth and acoustic emissions during the scratch hardness test on Cu110.

The scratch hardness tests can be finished within a couple of minutes with high precision and repeatability. Compared to conventional indentation procedures, the scratch hardness test in this study provides an alternative solution for hardness measurements, which is useful for quality control and the development of new materials.

Conclusion

In this study, we showcased the capacity of the NANOVEA Mechanical Tester in performing scratch hardness tests in compliance to ASTM G171-03. In addition to coating adhesion and scratch resistance, the scratch test at a constant load provides an alternative simple solution for comparing the hardness of materials. In contrast to conventional scratch hardness testers, NANOVEA Mechanical Testers offer optional modules for monitoring the evolution of coefficient of friction, acoustic emission and true depth in situ.

The Nano and Micro modules of a NANOVEA Mechanical Tester include ISO and ASTM compliant indentation, scratch and wear tester modes, providing the widest and most user-friendly range of testing available in a single system. NANOVEA’s unmatched range is an ideal solution for determining the full range of mechanical properties of thin or thick, soft or hard coatings, films and substrates, including hardness, Young’s modulus, fracture toughness, adhesion, wear resistance and many others.

Frequently Asked Questions About Scratch Hardness Testing

What is a scratch hardness test?

A scratch hardness test measures a material’s resistance to scratch and abrasion from a sharp object. A diamond stylus of specified geometry scratches the surface along a linear path under a constant normal force at a constant speed; the average width of the scratch is measured and used to calculate the scratch hardness number (HSp). It applies to metals, ceramics, polymers and coated surfaces.

How is the scratch hardness number calculated in ASTM G171?

ASTM G171 calculates the scratch hardness number from the normal force and the average scratch width: HSp = 8P/(πw²), where P is the normal force and w the scratch width. A wider scratch under the same load means a softer surface.

What scratch hardness did copper, aluminum and stainless steel show?

Under a 10 N load with a 120° conical diamond stylus of 200 µm tip radius, Al6061, Cu110 and SS304 showed scratch widths of 174, 220 and 89 µm, giving scratch hardness numbers of 0.84, 0.52 and 3.20 GPa respectively.

What else is recorded during a scratch hardness test?

The NANOVEA Mechanical Tester records the coefficient of friction, true depth and acoustic emission in situ. The true depth is the stylus penetration during the scratch minus the surface profile from the pre-scan. These signals give insight into mechanical failures during scratching.

How does scratch hardness compare with indentation hardness?

Scratch hardness tests can be finished within a couple of minutes with high precision and repeatability, and provide an alternative to conventional indentation procedures for comparing the hardness of materials, useful for quality control and new-material development.

Which NANOVEA instrument measures scratch hardness?

The NANOVEA PB1000 Mechanical Tester, whose mapping function created three parallel scratches per sample in an automated protocol. Its Nano and Micro modules also include ISO and ASTM compliant indentation, scratch and wear testing modes.

Need Reliable Scratch Hardness Testing?