Application Note | CAD Comparison Inspection

Machined Parts Inspection from a CAD Model Using 3D Profilometry

Dimension, Radius, and Roughness Checked Against the CAD Model in Under 40 Seconds

Close-up of a motorcycle engine with machined parts

Research & Experimental Testing

Duanjie Li

Visual Design & Editorial

Andrew Shore

Introduction

The demand for precision machining able to create complex geometries has been on the rise across a spectrum of industries. From aerospace, medical and automobile, to tech gears, machinery and musical instruments, the continuous innovation and evolution push expectations and accuracy standards to new heights. Consequently, we see the rise of the demand for rigorous inspection techniques and instruments to ensure the highest quality of the products.

Why 3D Non-Contact Profilometry Matters for Parts Inspection

Comparing properties of machined parts to their CAD models is essential to verify tolerances and adherence to production standards. Inspection during the service time is also crucial as wear and tear of the parts may call for their replacement. Identification of any deviations from the required specifications in a timely manner will help avoid costly repairs, production halts and tarnished reputation.

Unlike a touch probe technique, the NANOVEA Optical Profilers perform 3D surface scans with zero contact, allowing for quick, precise and non-destructive measurements of complex shapes with the highest accuracy.

Measurement Objective

In this application, we showcase NANOVEA HS2000, a 3D Non-Contact Profiler with a high-speed sensor, performing a comprehensive surface inspection of dimension, radius, and roughness. All in under 40 seconds.

NANOVEA ST500 Large Area

Optical 3D Profilometer

NANOVEA ST500 large area optical profilometer for non-contact 3D surface measurement

CAD Model

A precise measurement of the dimension and surface roughness of the machined part is critical to make sure it meets the desired specifications, tolerances and surface finishes. The 3D model and the engineering drawing of the part to be inspected are presented below.

3D CAD model of the curved machined part with the scanned face marked, and its dimensional drawing with edges of 6.35 radius
3D CAD model and dimensional CAD model of the machined part.

False Color View

The false color view of the CAD model and the scanned machined part surface are compared in Fig. 1 and Fig. 2. The height variation on the sample surface can be observed by the change in color.

Three 2D profiles are extracted from the 3D surface scan as indicated in Fig. 2 to further verify the dimensional tolerance of the machined part.

False-color 3D surface of the CAD model above the scanned machined part surface, with Profiles 1, 2 and 3 marked
Figure 1: 3D surface of the CAD model. Figure 2: 3D surface morphology of the machined part, with the extracted profiles.

Profiles Comparison and Results

Profile 1 through 3 are shown in Fig. 3 through 5. Quantitative tolerance inspection is carried out by comparing the measured profile with the CAD model to uphold rigorous manufacturing standards. Profile 1 and Profile 2 measure the radius of different areas on the curved machined part. The height variation of Profile 2 is 30 µm over a length of 156 mm which meets the desired ±125 µm tolerance requirement.

By setting up a tolerance limit value, the analysis software can automatically determine pass or fail of the machined part.

Profiles 1 and 2 extracted from the CAD model above the same profiles from the machined part scan
Figures 3 and 4: Profiles 1 and 2 on the imported CAD model and the machined part scan, for dimensional comparison.

The roughness and uniformity of the machined part’s surface play an important role in ensuring its quality and functionality. Fig. 6 is an extracted surface area from the parent scan of the machined part which was used to quantify the surface finish. The average surface roughness (Sa) was calculated to be 2.31 µm.

Profile 3 from the machined part scan for roughness analysis, with its ISO 4287 roughness values
Figure 5: Profile 3 from the machined part scan, with its roughness values.
ISO 4287 amplitude parameters, roughness profile (Profile 3)
ParameterValueDescription
Rp2.92 µmMaximum peak height of the roughness profile
Rv2.61 µmMaximum valley depth of the roughness profile
Rz5.53 µmMaximum height of roughness profile
Rc3.76 µmMean height of the roughness profile elements
Rt13.1 µmTotal height of roughness profile
Ra1.04 µmArithmetic mean deviation of the roughness profile
Rq1.30 µmRoot-mean-square (RMS) deviation of the roughness profile
Rsk0.149Skewness of the roughness profile
Rku3.00Kurtosis of the roughness profile

Table 1: Profile roughness values of Profile 3.

Area extracted from the machined part scan for surface roughness analysis, with its ISO 25178 values
Figure 6: Extracted area from the machined part scan for surface roughness analysis.
ISO 25178 height parameters (extracted area)
ParameterValueDescription
Sa2.31 µmArithmetic mean height
Sq3.04 µmRoot-mean-square height
Ssk−0.445Skewness
Sku30.1Kurtosis
Sp23.3 µmMaximum peak height
Sv146 µmMaximum pit height
Sz169 µmMaximum height

Table 2: Surface roughness values for the extracted area.

Conclusion

In this study, we have showcased how the NANOVEA HS2000 Non-Contact Profiler equipped with a high speed sensor performs comprehensive surface inspection of dimensions and roughness.

High-resolution scans enable users to measure detailed morphology and surface features of machined parts and to quantitatively compare them with their CAD models. The instrument is also capable of detecting any defects including scratches and cracks.

The advanced contour analysis serves as an unparalleled tool not only to determine whether the machined parts satisfy the set specifications, but also to evaluate the failure mechanisms of the worn components.

The data shown here represents only a portion of the calculations possible with the advanced analysis software that comes equipped with every NANOVEA Optical Profiler.

Frequently Asked Questions About Machined Part Inspection

Why compare machined parts to their CAD model?

Comparing a part to its CAD model verifies tolerances and adherence to production standards. Inspection during service also matters, since wear may call for replacement; finding deviations in time avoids costly repairs, production halts and reputational damage.

Why use a non-contact profilometer instead of a touch probe?

NANOVEA optical profilers scan the surface in 3D with zero contact, allowing quick, precise and non-destructive measurement of complex shapes with high accuracy.

How is dimensional tolerance checked from a 3D scan?

Profiles are extracted from the scan and compared with the same profiles on the CAD model. In this study Profile 2 showed a height variation of 30 µm over 156 mm, within the required ±125 µm tolerance, and a tolerance limit lets the software decide pass or fail automatically.

How is surface roughness of the machined part measured?

From the same scan: a profile gives ISO 4287 parameters (Ra 1.04 µm on Profile 3) and an extracted area gives ISO 25178 parameters, with an average surface roughness Sa of 2.31 µm.

How long does the inspection take?

The comprehensive inspection of dimension, radius and roughness was performed in under 40 seconds with a high-speed sensor.

Which NANOVEA instrument was used for machined part inspection?

The NANOVEA HS2000 non-contact profiler with a high-speed sensor. Its current large-area counterpart is the NANOVEA ST500, with ultrafast large-area measurement and a 400 mm continuous scan.

Need Reliable Machined Part Inspection?