Application Note | Composite Panel Inspection

Honeycomb Panel Surface Finish Using High-Speed 3D Profilometry

Roughness, Flatness, and Porosity of Two Honeycomb Panel Finishes for Paintability and Quality

Space shuttle launch in a cloud of exhaust

Research & Experimental Testing

Duanjie Li & Pierre Leroux

Visual Design & Editorial

Andrew Shore

Introduction

The honeycomb structure is widely used in the aerospace industry due to its minimal density and relative high strength. It can be made of various types of materials such as aluminum, fiber glass and advanced composites for aircraft and rocket applications. The surface texture, roughness, and porosity of the honeycomb panel plays an important role in its quality and paintability. Honeycomb panel surfaces, with optimal homogeneous textures, provide improved strength and adhesive failure resistance for protective paints. They also enhance corrosion and wear resistance and mitigate the cosmetic effects of the honeycomb panel layer.

Why 3D Profilometry Matters for Honeycomb Panel Inspection

Roughness, porosity, and texture of the honeycomb panel surface are critical to quantify for the final panel design. These surface qualities can directly correlate to the aesthetics and functional characteristics of the panel surface. A better understanding of the surface texture and porosity can help optimize the panel surface processing and manufacturability. A quantitative, precise, and reliable surface measurement of the honeycomb panel is needed to control surface parameters for application and painting requirements. The NANOVEA 3D Non-Contact sensors utilize unique chromatic confocal technology capable of precisely measuring these panel surfaces.

Measurement Objective

In this study, the NANOVEA HS2000 platform equipped with a high-speed Line Sensor was used to measure and compare two honeycomb panels with different surface finishes. We showcase the NANOVEA non-contact profilometer’s ability to provide fast and precise 3D profiling measurements and comprehensive in-depth analysis of the surface finish.

NANOVEA ST500 Large Area

Optical 3D Profilometer

NANOVEA ST500 large area optical profilometer for non-contact 3D surface measurement

Samples

High-speed line sensor above a honeycomb panel sample
Fig. 1: High-speed line sensor above a honeycomb panel sample.
Two honeycomb panel samples, one with a light finish and one with a brown finish
Fig. 2: Honeycomb panel samples.

Results and Discussion

The surface of two honeycomb panel samples with varied surface finishes, namely Sample 1 and Sample 2, were measured. The false color and 3D view of the Samples 1 and 2 surfaces are shown in Fig. 3 and Fig. 4, respectively. The roughness and flatness values were calculated by advanced analysis software and are compared in Table 1. Sample 2 exhibits a more porous surface compared to Sample 1. As a result, Sample 2 possesses a higher roughness Sa of 14.7 µm, compared to an Sa value of 4.27 µm for Sample 1.

False-color height maps over 10 mm of honeycomb panel Sample 1 and the more porous Sample 2
Fig. 3: False color view of the honeycomb panel surfaces (a) Sample 1 and (b) Sample 2.
Honeycomb panel Sample 1 and the 3D view of its surface
Honeycomb panel Sample 2 and the 3D view of its porous surface

Fig. 4: 3D view of the honeycomb panel surfaces (a) Sample 1 and (b) Sample 2.

ParameterSample 1Sample 2Description
ISO 25178: roughness
Sq (µm)4.9621Root-mean-square height
Sz (µm)0.288230Maximum height
Sa (µm)4.2714.7Arithmetic mean height
ISO 12781: flatness
FLTt (µm)28.173.5Peak-to-valley flatness deviation of the surface
FLTp (µm)16.316.9Peak-to-reference flatness deviation
FLTv (µm)11.856.6Reference-to-valley flatness deviation
FLTq (µm)4.439.66Root-mean-square flatness deviation

Table 1: The roughness and flatness values of the honeycomb panel surfaces.

The 2D profiles of the honeycomb panel surfaces were compared in Fig. 5, allowing users to have a visual comparison of the height change at different locations of the sample surface. We can observe that Sample 1 has a height variation of ~25 µm between the highest peak and lowest valley location. On the other hand, Sample 2 shows several deep pores across the 2D profile. The advanced analysis software has the ability to automatically locate and measure the depth of six relatively deep pores as shown in the table of Fig. 5(b), Sample 2. The deepest pore amongst the six possesses a maximum depth of nearly 90 µm (Step 4).

Profile across Sample 1 with about 25 micrometres of height variation, and across Sample 2 with six pores measured
Fig. 5: Cross section view of the honeycomb panel surfaces (a) Sample 1 and (b) Sample 2.
Pore (Sample 2)Step 1Step 2Step 3Step 4Step 5Step 6
Width (mm)0.1850.1000.0700.2550.0900.075
Maximum depth (µm)67.159.357.289.942.753.8
Mean depth (µm)58.341.649.875.735.938.7

Table 2: Pores located on the Sample 2 profile.

To further investigate the pore size and distribution of Sample 2, a porosity evaluation was performed and discussed in the following section. The sliced view is displayed in Fig. 6 and the results are summarized in Table 3. We can observe that the pores, marked in blue in Fig. 6, have a relatively homogeneous distribution on the sample surface. The pores’ projected area constitutes 18.9% of the whole sample surface. A cumulative pore volume of 0.06 mm³ per mm², 42.2 µm average depth and 108.1 µm maximum depth were calculated.

Porosity map of Sample 2 with pores below a 104 micrometre threshold marked in blue
Fig. 6: Porosity analysis.
Void parameterValue
Projected area18.9%
Volume6313393 µm³/mm²
Mean depth42.2 µm
Maximum depth108.1 µm

Table 3: Results summary of the porosity analysis.

Conclusion

In this application, we have showcased that the NANOVEA HS2000 platform equipped with a high-speed Line Sensor is an ideal tool for analyzing and comparing the surface finish of honeycomb panel samples in a fast and accurate manner. The high-resolution profilometry scans paired with an advanced analysis software allow for a comprehensive and quantitative evaluation of the surface finish of honeycomb panel samples.

The data shown here represents only a small portion of the calculations available in the analysis software. NANOVEA Profilometers measure virtually any surface for a wide range of applications in the Semiconductor, Microelectronic, Solar, Fiber Optics, Automotive, Aerospace, Metallurgy, Machining, Coatings, Pharmaceutical, Biomedical, Environmental and many other industries.

Frequently Asked Questions About Honeycomb Panel Surface Inspection

Why measure the surface of honeycomb panels?

Honeycomb structures are widely used in aerospace for their low density and high strength. The texture, roughness and porosity of the panel surface govern quality and paintability: homogeneous textures improve strength and adhesion of protective paints, corrosion and wear resistance, and cosmetic appearance.

How were the honeycomb panels measured?

An HS2000 platform with a high-speed chromatic confocal line sensor scanned 10 mm × 10 mm on each panel, giving 3D maps for roughness, flatness, cross-section profiles and porosity analysis.

How did the two panel finishes compare?

Sample 2 was more porous and rougher, with Sa 14.7 µm against 4.27 µm for Sample 1, and a flatness deviation FLTt of 73.5 µm against 28.1 µm.

How are pores measured on a panel surface?

The analysis software automatically locates pores on extracted profiles and measures their width and depth; on Sample 2 the deepest of six pores reached 89.9 µm. A porosity evaluation over the whole scan then gives pore area, volume and depth.

What did the porosity analysis show?

On Sample 2 the pores were distributed fairly homogeneously and covered 18.9% of the surface, with a cumulative volume of about 0.06 mm³ per mm², a mean depth of 42.2 µm and a maximum depth of 108.1 µm.

Which parameters describe panel flatness?

ISO 12781 flatness parameters: FLTt (peak-to-valley), FLTp (peak-to-reference), FLTv (reference-to-valley) and FLTq (root-mean-square flatness deviation).

Need Reliable Composite Panel Inspection?