Application Note | Dental Nanoindentation

Tooth Hardness Evaluation with Nanoindentation

Hardness and Elastic Modulus of Dentin, Decay, and Pulp to Guide Better-Matched Dental Fillings

Dental technician working on a dental model

Research & Experimental Testing

NANOVEA Laboratory

Visual Design & Editorial

Andrew Shore

Introduction

With many traditional mechanical tests (Hardness, Adhesion, Compression, Puncture, Yield Strength, etc.), today’s quality control environments with advanced sensitive materials, from gels to brittle materials, now require greater precision and reliability control. Traditional mechanical instrumentation fails to provide the sensitive load control and resolution required; designed to be used for bulk materials.

Why Nanoindentation Matters for Biomaterials

As the size of material being tested became of greater interest, the development of Nanoindentation provided a reliable method to obtain essential mechanical information on smaller surfaces such as the research being done with biomaterials. The challenges specifically associated with biomaterials have required the development of mechanical testing capable of accurate load control on extremely soft to brittle materials. Also, multiple instruments are needed to perform various mechanical tests which can now be performed on a single system. Nanoindentation provides a wide range of measurement with precise resolution at nano controlled loads for sensitive applications.

Measurement Objective

In this application, the NANOVEA Mechanical Tester, in Nanoindentation mode, is used to study the hardness and elastic modulus of the dentin, decay, and pulp of a tooth. The most critical aspect with Nanoindentation testing is securing the sample, here we took a sliced tooth and epoxy mounted leaving all three areas of interest exposed for testing.

NANOVEA PB1000 Large Platform

Mechanical Tester

Nanoindenter and scratch tester platform NANOVEA PB1000 with nano and micro modules

Test Conditions

Epoxy-mounted tooth slice clamped under the nanoindentation module
Fig. 1: Sample of tooth being analyzed with the NANOVEA Mechanical Tester.
Test conditionAll samples
Maximum force30 mN
Loading rate60 mN/min
Unloading rate60 mN/min
Creep20 s
Computation methodNANOVEA
Indenter typeBerkovich diamond

Table 1: Nanoindentation test conditions.

Results and Discussion

This section includes a summary table that compares the main numerical results for the different samples, followed by the full result listings, including each indentation performed, accompanied by micrographs of the indentation, when available. These full results present the measured values of Hardness and Young’s modulus as the penetration depth with their averages and standard deviations. It should be considered that large variation in the results can occur in the case that the surface roughness is in the same size range as the indentation.

ZoneHardness (Vickers)Hardness (GPa)Young’s modulus (GPa)Depth (nm)
Dentin83.0 ± 3.00.878 ± 0.03217.9 ± 0.51360 ± 19
Decay24.3 ± 5.10.257 ± 0.0544.58 ± 0.473329 ± 310
Pulp20.5 ± 0.30.217 ± 0.0043.49 ± 0.073643 ± 32

Table 2: Summary of main numerical results.

Epoxy-mounted tooth slice with the dentin, pulp and decay zones circled
Fig. 2: Tooth sample with the dentin, decay and pulp test zones.

Dentin

Load-depth curve of a dentin indent to about 1.4 µm and a 500x micrograph of the indent
Fig. 3: Loading curve and micrograph (500x), dentin, indent 1.

Decay

IndentHardness (Vickers)Hardness (GPa)Young’s modulus (GPa)Max depth (nm)
129.00.3075.073054
225.00.2644.533268
318.90.2004.133665
Average24.30.2574.583329
Standard deviation5.10.0540.47310

Table 3: Detailed nanoindentation results, decay.

Load-depth curve of a decay indent and a micrograph of the decayed area
Fig. 4: Loading curve (indent 1) and micrograph, decay area.

Pulp

IndentHardness (Vickers)Hardness (GPa)Young’s modulus (GPa)Max depth (nm)
120.90.2213.573606
220.30.2153.443668
320.40.2163.473656
Average20.50.2173.493643
Standard deviation0.30.0040.0732

Table 4: Detailed nanoindentation results, pulp.

Load-depth curve of a pulp indent and a micrograph of the pulp indent
Fig. 5: Loading curve (indent 1) and micrograph, pulp.

Conclusion

In conclusion, we have shown how the NANOVEA Mechanical Tester, in Nanoindentation mode, provides precise measurement of the mechanical properties of a tooth. The data can be used in the development of fillings that will better match the mechanical characteristics of a real tooth. The positioning capability of the NANOVEA Mechanical Tester allows full mapping of the hardness of the teeth across the various zones.

Using the same system, it is possible to test teeth material fracture toughness at higher loads up to 200 N. A multi-cycle loading test can be used on more porous materials to evaluate the remaining level of elasticity. Using a flat cylindrical diamond tip can give yield strength information in each zone. In addition, with DMA “Dynamic Mechanical Analysis”, the viscoelastic properties including loss and storage moduli can be evaluated.

The NANOVEA nano module is ideal for these tests because it uses a unique feedback response to control precisely the load applied. Because of this, the nano module can also be used to do accurate nano scratch testing. The study of scratch and wear resistance of tooth material and filling materials adds to the overall usefulness of the Mechanical tester. Using a sharp 2-micron tip to quantitatively compare marring on filling materials will allow better prediction of the behavior in real applications. Multi-pass wear or direct rotative wear testing are also common tests providing important information on the long term viability.

Frequently Asked Questions About Tooth Nanoindentation

Why use nanoindentation on teeth and biomaterials?

Traditional mechanical instrumentation was designed for bulk materials and lacks the load control and resolution needed for small areas of extremely soft to brittle biomaterials. Nanoindentation gives precise resolution at nano-controlled loads on small surfaces such as the zones of a tooth.

How is a tooth prepared for nanoindentation?

Securing the sample is the most critical aspect. Here a sliced tooth was epoxy mounted, leaving the dentin, decay and pulp areas exposed for testing.

What test conditions were used?

A Berkovich diamond indenter loaded to 30 mN at 60 mN/min, held for a 20 s creep, and unloaded at 60 mN/min, with NANOVEA computation of hardness and modulus.

How hard are dentin, decay and pulp?

Dentin measured 83.0 ± 3.0 HV (0.878 GPa) with a Young’s modulus of 17.9 GPa, decay 24.3 ± 5.1 HV (0.257 GPa, 4.58 GPa) and pulp 20.5 ± 0.3 HV (0.217 GPa, 3.49 GPa).

How can tooth hardness data be used?

It supports the development of fillings that better match the mechanical characteristics of a real tooth, and the tester’s positioning capability allows full hardness mapping across the zones of a tooth.

What other dental tests can the same system perform?

Fracture toughness at loads up to 200 N, multi-cycle loading on porous materials, yield strength with a flat cylindrical tip, DMA loss and storage moduli, nano scratch and marring tests with a sharp 2 µm tip, and multi-pass or rotative wear of tooth and filling materials.

Need Reliable Dental Material Testing?