Application Note | Photovoltaic Inspection

Surface Roughness and Features of a Solar Cell

Roughness and Gridline Geometry of a Monocrystalline Photovoltaic Cell for Quality Control

Solar panels on a rooftop

Research & Experimental Testing

NANOVEA Laboratory

Visual Design & Editorial

Andrew Shore

Introduction

Maximizing a solar cell’s energy absorption is key for the technology’s survival as a renewable resource. The multiple layers of coating and glass protection allow for the absorption, transmittance, and reflection of light that is necessary for the photovoltaic cells to function. Given that most consumer solar cells operate at 15–18% efficiency, optimizing their energy output is an ongoing battle.

Why Surface Roughness Matters for Solar Panels

Studies have shown that surface roughness plays a pivotal role in the reflectance of light. The initial layer of glass must be as smooth as possible to mitigate the reflectance of light, but the subsequent layers do not follow this guideline. A degree of roughness is necessary at each coatings interface to another to increase the possibility of light scattering within their respective depletion zones and increase the absorption of light within the cell1. Optimizing the surface roughness in these regions allows the solar cell to operate to the best of its ability and with the NANOVEA HS2000 High Speed Sensor, measuring surface roughness can be done quickly and accurately.

Measurement Objective

In this study we will display the capabilities of the NANOVEA Profilometer HS2000 with High Speed Sensor by measuring the surface roughness and geometric features of a photovoltaic cell. For this demonstration a monocrystalline solar cell with no glass protection will be measured but the methodology can be used for various other applications.

NANOVEA ST500 Large Area

Optical 3D Profilometer

NANOVEA ST500 large area optical profilometer for non-contact 3D surface measurement

Test Procedure

Monocrystalline solar cell on the stage under the optical pen of the NANOVEA HS2000L profilometer
Solar cell sample on the NANOVEA HS2000L profilometer.

The following test parameters were used to measure the surface of the solar cell.

ParameterValue
Optical penL1
Acquisition rate100 pps
Averaging1
Measured surface30 mm × 10 mm
Step size5 µm × 5 µm
Measurement time00:13:43 (h:m:s)
Square monocrystalline solar cell with two busbars and fine gridlines
Sample of solar cell analyzed.

Table 1: Test parameters used.

Results and Discussion

Depicted below is the 2D false-color view of the solar cell and an area extraction of the surface with its respective height parameters. A Gaussian filter was applied to both surfaces and a more aggressive index was used to flatten the extracted area. This excludes form (or waviness) larger than the cut-off index, leaving behind features that represent the solar cell’s roughness.

Strip of the solar cell with its false-color height map across a gridline and busbar, and the 3D view of the same area
Figs. 1–2: False color view (Fig. 1) and 3D view (Fig. 2) of the photovoltaic cell.
Extracted area of the first layer of the cell with its false-color roughness map and ISO 25178 height parameters
Fig. 3: Surface roughness of the first layer of the photovoltaic surface.
ISO 25178 parameterValue
Sa0.3899 µm
Sq0.5160 µm
Sp2.214 µm
Sv1.744 µm
Sz3.958 µm
Ssk−0.1978
Sku3.975
Spar7.284 mm²
Sdar7.377 mm²

Table 2: Height parameters of the extracted area shown in Fig. 3.

3D view of the roughness of the first layer of the photovoltaic surface
Fig. 4: 3D view of the first layer of the photovoltaic surface.
Profile across the first layer of the cell with its ISO 4287 amplitude parameters
Fig. 5: Profile roughness amplitude parameters of the first layer of the photovoltaic surface.
ISO 4287 parameterValueDescription
Primary profile
Pq0.5155 µmRoot-mean-square deviation of the raw profile
Pp1.706 µmMaximum peak height of the raw profile
Pv1.635 µmMaximum valley depth of the raw profile
Pz3.341 µmMaximum height of the raw profile
Pc1.109 µmMean height of the raw profile elements (ISO 4287 without amendment 2)
Pt3.341 µmTotal height of the raw profile
Pa0.3863 µmArithmetic mean deviation of the raw profile
Roughness profile (Gaussian filter, 0.8 mm)
Rq0.5155 µmRoot-mean-square deviation of the roughness profile
Rp1.064 µmMaximum peak height of the roughness profile
Rv1.677 µmMaximum valley depth of the roughness profile
Rz2.741 µmMaximum height of the roughness profile
Rc1.225 µmMean height of the roughness profile elements
Rt3.341 µmTotal height of the roughness profile
Ra0.3845 µmArithmetic mean deviation of the roughness profile

Table 3: Amplitude parameters of the profile shown in Fig. 5.

A profile was taken perpendicular to the orientation of the gridlines to measure their geometric characteristics which is shown below. The gridline width, step height, and pitch can be measured for any specific location on the solar cell.

Profile across two gridlines with their widths of 0.1100 and 0.1252 mm measured
Fig. 6: Width measurement of the gridline.
Profile across three gridlines with pitches of 1.9450 and 1.9350 mm
Fig. 7: Pitch measurement of the gridline.
Profile across three gridlines with their step heights measured
Fig. 8: Step height measurement of the gridline.
Gridline featureValue
Gridline width (two gridlines)0.1100 mm and 0.1252 mm
Gridline pitch1.9450 mm and 1.9350 mm
Gridline step height, maximum (Steps 1–3)10.48, 10.24 and 12.30 µm
Gridline step height, mean (Steps 1–3)9.130, 8.972 and 11.75 µm

Table 4: Gridline dimensions measured in Figs. 6 to 8.

Conclusion

In this study we were able to display the NANOVEA HS2000 Line Sensor’s ability to measure a monocrystalline photovoltaic cell’s surface roughness and features. With the ability to automate accurate measurements of multiple samples and set pass fail limits, the NANOVEA HS2000 Line Sensor is a perfect choice for quality control inspections.

References

1. Scholtz, Lubomir; Ladanyi, Libor; Mullerova, Jarmila. “Influence of Surface Roughness on Optical Characteristics of Multilayer Solar Cells.” Advances in Electrical and Electronic Engineering, vol. 12, no. 6, 2014, pp. 631–638.

Frequently Asked Questions About Solar Cell Surface Measurement

Why does surface roughness matter in solar cells?

Surface roughness plays a pivotal role in light reflectance. The outer glass must be as smooth as possible to limit reflection, while a degree of roughness at each internal coating interface increases light scattering in the depletion zones and the light absorbed by the cell. With most consumer solar cells operating at 15–18% efficiency, optimizing roughness matters.

How was the solar cell measured?

A NANOVEA HS2000 profilometer with a high-speed line sensor scanned 30 mm × 10 mm of a monocrystalline cell without glass protection at a 5 µm × 5 µm step, using the L1 optical pen, in 13 minutes 43 seconds.

What roughness did the photovoltaic surface show?

On an extracted, flattened area the ISO 25178 roughness was Sa 0.3899 µm, Sq 0.5160 µm and Sz 3.958 µm; along a profile the ISO 4287 roughness was Ra 0.3845 µm with a 0.8 mm Gaussian filter.

Can gridline dimensions be measured from the same scan?

Yes. A profile across the gridlines gives their width (0.1100 and 0.1252 mm), pitch (1.9450 and 1.9350 mm) and step height (maximum 10.24 to 12.30 µm) at any location on the cell.

Why filter the scan before calculating roughness?

A Gaussian filter removes form and waviness larger than the cut-off, leaving the features that represent the cell’s roughness; a more aggressive cut-off was used to flatten the extracted area.

Can solar cell inspection be automated?

Yes. The HS2000 line sensor can automate accurate measurements of multiple samples with pass/fail limits, making it suited to quality control inspection.

Need Reliable Solar Cell Inspection?