Application Note | Abrasives Testing

Sandpaper Abrasion Performance Testing Under Dry and Wet Conditions

Quantifying the Abrasive Performance of Two P220 Grit Sandpapers with Friction and Wear Volume

Assorted sandpaper sheets, disks and flap discs

Research & Experimental Testing

Duanjie Li

Visual Design & Editorial

Andrew Shore

Introduction

Sandpaper consists of abrasive particles glued to one face of a paper or cloth. Various abrasive materials can be used for the particles, such as garnet, silicon carbide, aluminum oxide and diamond. Sandpaper is widely applied in a variety of industrial sectors to create specific surface finishes on wood, metal and drywall. They often work under high pressure contact applied by hand or power tools.

Why Evaluating Sandpaper Abrasion Performance Matters

The effectiveness of sandpaper is often determined by its abrasion performance under different conditions. The grit size, i.e. the size of the abrasive particles embedded in the sandpaper, determines the wear rate and the scratch size of the material being sanded. Sandpapers of higher grit numbers have smaller particles, resulting in lower sanding speeds and finer surface finishes. Sandpapers with the same grit number but made of different materials can have unalike behaviors under dry or wet conditions. Reliable tribological evaluations are needed to ensure that manufactured sandpaper possesses the desired abrasive behavior intended. These evaluations allow users to quantitatively compare the wear behaviors of different types of sandpapers in a controlled and monitored manner in order to select the best candidate for the target application.

Measurement Objective

In this study, we showcase the NANOVEA T2000 High Load Pneumatic Tribometer’s ability to quantitatively evaluate the abrasion performance of various sandpaper samples under dry and wet conditions.

NANOVEA T2000 High Load

Pneumatic Tribometer

NANOVEA T2000 high load pneumatic tribometer

Test Procedures

The coefficient of friction (COF) and the abrasion performance of two types of sandpapers were evaluated by the NANOVEA T100 Tribometer. A 440 stainless steel ball was used as the counter material. The ball wear scars were examined after each wear test using the NANOVEA 3D Non-Contact Optical Profiler to ensure precise volume loss measurements.

Please note that a 440 stainless steel ball was chosen as the counter material to create a comparative study but any solid material could be substituted to simulate a different application condition.

ParameterValue
Ball materialSS440
Ball diameter6 mm
Test materialP220 grit sandpaper (2 types)
Normal force5 N
Rotational speed100 rpm
Duration of test5 min
Wear track radius10 mm
ConditionDry and wet
Temperature24°C (RT)

Test parameters of the wear measurement.

Steel ball holder of the tribometer on a red sandpaper disk with a circular wear track
Wet abrasion test on a sandpaper sample.

Test Results and Discussion

Fig. 1 shows a COF comparison of Sandpaper 1 and 2 under dry and wet environmental conditions. Sandpaper 1, under dry conditions, shows a COF of 0.4 at the beginning of the test which progressively decreases and stabilizes to 0.3. Under wet conditions, this sample exhibits a lower average COF of 0.27. In contrast, Sample 2’s COF results show a dry COF of 0.27 and wet COF of ~0.37.

Please note the oscillation in the data for all COF plots was caused by the vibrations generated by the sliding movement of the ball against the rough sandpaper surfaces.

Coefficient of friction versus revolutions for Sandpaper 1 and 2 under dry and wet conditions
Fig. 1: Evolution of COF during the wear tests.

Fig. 2 summarizes the results of the wear scar analysis. The wear scars were measured using an optical microscope and a NANOVEA 3D Non-Contact Optical Profiler. Fig. 3 and Fig. 4 compare the wear scars of the worn SS440 balls post wear tests on Sandpaper 1 and 2 (wet and dry conditions). As shown in Fig. 4 the NANOVEA Optical Profiler precisely captures the surface topography of the four balls and their respective wear tracks which were then processed with the NANOVEA Mountains Advanced Analysis software to calculate volume loss and wear rate. On the microscope and profile image of the ball it can be observed that the ball used for Sandpaper 1 (dry) testing exhibited a larger flattened wear scar compared to the others with a volume loss of 0.313 mm³. In contrast, the volume loss for Sandpaper 1 (wet) was 0.131 mm³. For Sandpaper 2 (dry) the volume loss was 0.163 mm³ and for Sandpaper 2 (wet) the volume loss increased to 0.237 mm³.

Moreover, it is interesting to observe that the COF played an important role in the abrasion performance of the sandpapers. Sandpaper 1 exhibited higher COF in the dry condition, leading to a higher abrasion rate for the SS440 ball used in the test. In comparison, the higher COF of Sandpaper 2 in the wet condition resulted in a higher abrasion rate. The wear tracks of the sandpapers after the measurements are displayed in Fig. 5.

Both Sandpapers 1 and 2 claim to work in either dry or wet environments. However, they exhibited significantly different abrasion performance in the dry and wet conditions. NANOVEA tribometers provide well-controlled quantifiable and reliable wear assessment capabilities that ensure reproducible wear evaluations. Moreover, the capacity of in situ COF measurement allows users to correlate different stages of a wear process with the evolution of COF, which is critical in improving fundamental understanding of the wear mechanism and tribological characteristics of sandpaper.

Bar chart of ball wear volume with average coefficient of friction for Sandpaper 1 and 2, dry and wet
SandpaperConditionBall volume loss (mm³)
Sandpaper 1Dry0.313
Sandpaper 1Wet0.131
Sandpaper 2Dry0.163
Sandpaper 2Wet0.237

Fig. 2: Wear scar volume of the balls and average COF under different conditions.

Microscope image of the flattened wear scar on the SS440 ball after testing on Sandpaper 1, dry
Microscope image of the flattened wear scar on the SS440 ball after testing on Sandpaper 2, dry
Microscope image of the flattened wear scar on the SS440 ball after testing on Sandpaper 1, wet
Microscope image of the flattened wear scar on the SS440 ball after testing on Sandpaper 2, wet

Fig. 3: Wear scars of the balls after the tests.

3D profilometer view of the wear scar on the SS440 ball after testing on Sandpaper 1, dry
3D profilometer view of the wear scar on the SS440 ball after testing on Sandpaper 2, dry
3D profilometer view of the wear scar on the SS440 ball after testing on Sandpaper 1, wet
3D profilometer view of the wear scar on the SS440 ball after testing on Sandpaper 2, wet

Fig. 4: 3D morphology of the wear scars on the balls.

Microscope image of the wear track on Sandpaper 1, dry
Microscope image of the wear track on Sandpaper 2, dry
Microscope image of the wear track on Sandpaper 1, wet
Microscope image of the wear track on Sandpaper 2, wet

Fig. 5: Wear tracks on the sandpapers under different conditions.

Conclusion

The abrasion performance of two types of sandpapers of the same grit number were evaluated under dry and wet conditions in this study. The service conditions of the sandpaper play a critical role in the effectiveness of the work performance. Sandpaper 1 possessed significantly better abrasion behavior under dry conditions, while Sandpaper 2 performed better under wet conditions. The friction during the sanding process is an important factor to consider when evaluating abrasion performance. The NANOVEA Optical Profiler precisely measures the 3D morphology of any surface, such as wear scars on a ball, ensuring reliable evaluation on the abrasion performance of the sandpaper in this study.

The NANOVEA Tribometer measures the coefficient of friction in situ during a wear test, providing an insight on the different stages of a wear process. It also offers repeatable wear and friction testing using ISO and ASTM compliant rotative and linear modes, with optional high temperature wear and lubrication modules available in one pre-integrated system. This unmatched range allows users to simulate different severe work environments including high stress, wear and high temperature, etc. It also provides an ideal tool to quantitatively assess the tribological behaviors of superior wear resistant materials under high loads.

Frequently Asked Questions About Sandpaper Abrasion Testing

Why test the abrasion performance of sandpaper?

The effectiveness of sandpaper is often determined by its abrasion performance under different conditions. Sandpapers with the same grit number but made of different materials can behave differently dry or wet, so reliable tribological evaluation ensures manufactured sandpaper has the intended abrasive behavior and lets users select the best candidate for an application.

How is sandpaper abrasion measured on a tribometer?

A 6 mm SS440 steel ball slides on the sandpaper in rotative mode, here at 5 N and 100 rpm on a 10 mm radius for 5 minutes, while the coefficient of friction is recorded. The volume lost from the ball, measured with a 3D non-contact optical profiler, quantifies the abrasion.

Do sandpapers perform the same wet and dry?

Not necessarily. Both sandpapers in this study claim to work in dry and wet environments, yet Sandpaper 1 abraded the ball most when dry (0.313 mm³ against 0.131 mm³ wet), while Sandpaper 2 abraded it most when wet (0.237 mm³ against 0.163 mm³ dry).

How does friction relate to sandpaper abrasion?

In this study the higher coefficient of friction went with the higher abrasion rate: Sandpaper 1 had its higher COF in the dry condition and Sandpaper 2 in the wet condition. In situ COF measurement lets users correlate the stages of a wear process with friction.

How does grit size affect sanding?

The grit size, the size of the abrasive particles, determines the wear rate and the scratch size on the sanded material. Sandpapers of higher grit numbers have smaller particles, giving lower sanding speeds and finer surface finishes.

Which NANOVEA instruments were used for sandpaper abrasion testing?

A NANOVEA tribometer for the wear tests with in situ friction, and the NANOVEA 3D Non-Contact Optical Profiler with Mountains Advanced Analysis software to calculate the volume loss of the balls.

Need Reliable Abrasion Testing?