Application Note | Edge Chipping

Edge Chipping Resistance Using Macroindentation Testing

Load at Failure Versus Distance from the Edge, with Acoustic Emission Detection of Chipping

Indenter and depth sensor over a ceramic block

Research & Experimental Testing

Ali Mansouri

Visual Design & Editorial

Andrew Shore

Introduction

The resistance of the edges of brittle materials to chipping or flaking from concentrated loads is a critical property for dental restoration ceramics, resin composites, edge-mounted optical devices, ceramic tool bits, thin semiconductor chips, and many other materials. The edge chipping resistance test provides a method to quantify and measure the fracture resistance, toughness, and edge chip strength of these materials. This method uses a conical indenter to chip the rectangular edge of a brittle sample at set distances from the edge. Archeological evidence has revealed that this method is similar to the way early humans selected stones to make tools and weapons. Hundreds of thousands of years later, edge chipping tests remain a critical tool for applications where edge toughness is concerned.

Why Measure Edge Chipping Resistance

Edge chipping concentrates load at a free edge, where brittle materials are weakest. Measuring the load at which an edge flakes, and how it changes with distance from the edge, gives a quantitative edge toughness that can be compared between materials, processes and finishing methods.

ℹ️ Learn more about indentation testing lab services.

Measurement Objective

In this application, the NANOVEA Mechanical Tester, in Macroindentation Mode, is used to evaluate the edge chipping resistance of a thin ceramic block. Using a Rockwell C indenter to apply a point load at set distances between 0.05 and 0.40 mm from the edge of the sample, we will identify the flaking load at which the edge will chip.

NANOVEA PB1000 Large Platform

Mechanical Tester

Nanoindenter and scratch tester platform NANOVEA PB1000 with nano and micro modules
Rockwell indenter and depth sensor above the edge of a thin ceramic block
Fig. 1: Indenter and depth sensor on the test sample.

Test Conditions

The 50x50x2 mm ceramic block was carefully fixed on the sample stage. The indenter tip used was a diamond Rockwell C conical tip of 200 μm diameter. The PID settings were set such that the test stops upon a sudden drop in load. The NANOVEA Mechanical Tester was used to perform the Macroindentation tests using the test parameters summarized in Table 1, in order to evaluate the load at which edge chipping occurred on the ceramic sample.

Test parameterValue
Maximum force400 N (the test stops upon failure)
Loading rate20 N/min
Indenter geometryConical
Indenter material (tip)Diamond
Indenter tip radius20 μm

Table 1: Test parameters of the macroindentation measurements.

Results and Discussion

Several different tests were performed at distances between 0.05 and 0.40 mm from the edge of the sample. The test location was precisely determined using an optical microscope with a previously calibrated microscope-indenter distance. NANOVEA’s control software ensured the load was immediately removed upon chipping. The acoustic emissions module also helped determine the exact time failure occurred. Table 2 shows the mean load at failure for each distance.

Distance from edge (μm)Mean load at failure (N)
5032.12
10075.87
15089.73
200145.50
250175.85
300149.30
350210.40
400261.10

Table 2: Edge chipping test results.

A graph showing the results of 15 different edge chipping tests, along with a superimposed linear regression line is shown in Fig. 2. As can be seen, there was a very strong closeness of fit between the data and the linear regression line.

Load at failure against distance from the sample edge for 15 tests with a linear fit y = 0.6107x + 8.4978, R² = 0.9371
Fig. 2: Load at failure vs distance from the sample edge.

The maximum load before chipping occurred can be derived from the Load vs Time Graph of each test, such as the one seen in Fig. 3. Sudden failure creates a clear acoustic emission that can be detected by the NANOVEA Mechanical Tester and is shown as a black vertical line. Any continued load application after chipping (overchipping) would show up on the graph as a sudden departure from the linear Load vs Time line. Overchipping can be reduced or prevented using NANOVEA’s control software.

Load rising linearly with time up to the chipping failure
Fig. 3: Load vs time graph for the test 250 µm from the edge.

The chips themselves can be studied under an optical microscope after the testing is complete. As can be seen in Fig. 4, the chips get progressively wider and deeper the farther away the load is applied from the edge. These can be further characterized to determine the exact surface area and volume lost, as well as get a high resolution 3D topography map using the NANOVEA Profilometer.

Four micrographs of edge chips made 50, 100, 150 and 200 µm from the edge, growing wider with distance
Fig. 4: Micrographs of chipping at (a) 50, (b) 100, (c) 150 and (d) 200 µm from the edge, 100x magnification.

Conclusion

In this study, we have shown how the NANOVEA Mechanical Tester, in Macroindentation mode, can perform an edge chipping test on a brittle material. The distances from the edge were precisely determined using an optical microscope. It was shown that the load feedback loop, along with the acoustic emissions module can be used to identify the exact point before chipping failure occurs. The system can also extend in the micro and nano range for materials needing much lower loads for failure. Edge chipping testing can be done at different environmental conditions using temperature and humidity modules. By allowing the application of a precisely controlled load at a desired position, the NANOVEA Mechanical Tester provides a superior tool to quantitatively evaluate and compare the edge chipping resistance of various brittle materials.

The Nano, Micro or Macro modules of the NANOVEA Mechanical Tester all include ISO and ASTM compliant indentation, scratch and wear tester modes, providing the widest and most user friendly range of testing available in a single system.

Frequently Asked Questions About Edge Chipping Testing

What does an edge chipping test measure?

The resistance of a brittle material’s edge to chipping or flaking under a concentrated load, quantifying fracture resistance, toughness and edge chip strength, which matters for dental ceramics, resin composites, optics, ceramic tool bits and thin semiconductor chips.

How is the test done?

A conical indenter loads the rectangular edge of the sample at set distances from the edge, and the load at which the edge chips is recorded. Here a Rockwell C diamond indented a 50 × 50 × 2 mm ceramic block at 50 to 400 µm from the edge at 20 N/min.

How does the failure load change with distance?

It increases with distance from the edge, from 32.12 N at 50 µm to 261.10 N at 400 µm; a linear regression over 15 tests gave y = 0.6107x + 8.4978 with R² = 0.9371.

How is the moment of chipping detected?

The PID load control stops the test on a sudden drop in load, and the acoustic emission module records a clear signal at failure, preventing over-chipping after the chip forms.

What do the chips look like?

Under the microscope the chips become progressively wider and deeper the farther from the edge the load is applied; a profilometer can measure their exact area and volume.

Can the test be run at lower loads or in other environments?

Yes. The system extends to the micro and nano range for materials that fail at much lower loads, and temperature and humidity modules allow testing under different conditions.

Need to Measure Edge Toughness?