Application Note | Soft Tissue Nanoindentation

Biological Tissue Hardness Evaluation Using Nanoindentation

Hardness, Elastic Modulus, and Creep of Fat and Meat Regions Measured at Sub-mN Loads

Biomedical laboratory work at an analyzer

Research & Experimental Testing

NANOVEA Laboratory

Visual Design & Editorial

Andrew Shore

Introduction

Traditional mechanical tests (hardness, adhesion, compression, puncture, yield strength, etc.) require greater precision and reliability in today’s quality control environments with a wide range of advanced materials from tissues to brittle materials. Traditional mechanical instrumentation fails to provide the sensitive load control and resolution required for advanced materials.

Why Biological Tissue Nanoindentation Matters

The challenges associated with biomaterials require developing mechanical tests capable of accurate load control on extremely soft materials. These materials require very low sub mN testing loads with large depth range to ensure proper property measurement. In addition, many different mechanical test types can be performed on a single system allowing for greater functionality. This provides a range of important measurements on biomaterials including hardness, elastic modulus, loss and storage modulus, and creep in addition to scratch resistance and yield strength failure points.

Measurement Objective

In this application NANOVEA’s mechanical tester in nanoindentation mode is used to study the hardness and elastic modulus of 3 separate areas of a biomaterial substitute on fat, light meat, and dark meat regions of prosciutto.

NANOVEA PB1000 Large Platform

Mechanical Tester

Nanoindenter and scratch tester platform NANOVEA PB1000 with nano and micro modules

Nanoindentation Method

Nanoindentation is based on instrumented indentation standards ASTM E2546 and ISO 14577. It uses established methods where an indenter tip of known geometry is driven into a specific site of the test material with a controlled increasing normal load. When reaching a pre-set maximum depth, normal load is reduced until complete relaxation occurs. Load is applied by a piezo actuator and measured in a controlled loop with a high sensitivity load cell. During experiments the indenter position relative to the sample surface is monitored with a high precision capacitive sensor. The resulting load and displacement curves provide data specific to the mechanical nature of the tested material. Established models calculate quantitative hardness and modulus values with the measured data. Nanoindentation is suited to low load and penetration depth measurements at nanometer scales.

Results and Discussion

These tables below present measured values of hardness and Young’s modulus with averages and standard deviations. High surface roughness may cause large variations in the results due to small indentation size.

Test areaHardness (kPa)Young’s modulus (kPa)Creep (µm)
Fat37.5 ± 1.1548 ± 6020.1 ± 3.5
Light meat67.2 ± 6.8570 ± 8014.0 ± 1.0
Dark meat95.2 ± 5.6834 ± 1269.3 ± 0.9

Table 1: Summary of nanoindentation results on the three areas.

The fat area had about half the hardness of the meat areas. Meat treatment caused the darker meat area to be harder than the light meat area. Elastic modulus and hardness are in direct relation to mouth feel chewiness of the fat and meat areas. The fat and light meat area have creep continuing at a higher rate than the dark meat after 60 seconds.

Detailed Results: Fat

TestHardness (kPa)Young’s modulus (kPa)Creep (µm)
137.451624.7
237.161719.6
339.353815.9
436.547117.7
537.259922.5
Average37.554820.1
Standard deviation1.1603.5

Table 2: Nanoindentation results on the fat area.

Load versus depth curve of a nanoindentation on the fat area, loaded to about 1 mN with a creep hold
Fig. 2: Loading curve, fat area.
Creep depth versus time over 60 seconds on the fat area
Fig. 3: Creep curve, fat area.

Detailed Results: Light Meat

TestHardness (kPa)Young’s modulus (kPa)Creep (µm)
160.756515.2
260.456714.9
376.369913.5
471.248013.1
567.553913.3
Average67.257014.0
Standard deviation6.8801.0

Table 3: Nanoindentation results on the light meat area.

Load versus depth curve of a nanoindentation on the light meat area, loaded to about 1 mN with a creep hold
Fig. 4: Loading curve, light meat area.
Creep depth versus time over 60 seconds on the light meat area
Fig. 5: Creep curve, light meat area.

Detailed Results: Dark Meat

TestHardness (kPa)Young’s modulus (kPa)Creep (µm)
1101.76848.8
290.174210.6
389.58489.6
4100.18919.6
594.310058.1
Average95.28349.3
Standard deviation5.61260.9

Table 4: Nanoindentation results on the dark meat area.

Load versus depth curve of a nanoindentation on the dark meat area, loaded to about 1 mN with a creep hold
Fig. 6: Loading curve, dark meat area.
Creep depth versus time over 60 seconds on the dark meat area
Fig. 7: Creep curve, dark meat area.

Conclusion

In this application, NANOVEA’s mechanical tester in nanoindentation mode reliably determined mechanical properties of the fat and meat areas while overcoming high sample surface roughness. This demonstrated the wide and unmatched capability of NANOVEA’s mechanical tester. The system simultaneously provides precise mechanical property measurements on extremely hard materials and soft biological tissues.

The load cell in closed loop control with the piezo table ensures precise measurement of hard or soft gel materials from 1 to 5 kPa. Using the same system, it is possible to test biomaterials at higher loads up to 400 N. Multi-cycle loading can be used for fatigue testing and yield strength information in each zone can be obtained using a flat cylindrical diamond tip. In addition, with Dynamic Mechanical Analysis (DMA), the viscoelastic properties loss and storage moduli can be evaluated with high accuracy using the closed loop load control. Tests at various temperatures and under liquids are also available on the same system.

NANOVEA’s mechanical tester continues to be the superior tool for biological and soft polymer/gel applications.

Frequently Asked Questions About Biological Tissue Nanoindentation

Why is nanoindentation of biological tissue challenging?

Biomaterials require mechanical tests with accurate load control on extremely soft materials: very low, sub-mN testing loads with a large depth range. Traditional mechanical instrumentation fails to provide the sensitive load control and resolution required.

How does nanoindentation work?

Following ASTM E2546 and ISO 14577, an indenter of known geometry is driven into the material under a controlled increasing load, then unloaded. A piezo applies the load in a closed loop with a high-sensitivity load cell while a capacitive sensor tracks the indenter position, and established models calculate hardness and modulus from the curves.

What hardness did the fat and meat regions show?

The fat area measured 37.5 ± 1.1 kPa, about half the hardness of the meat areas: 67.2 ± 6.8 kPa for light meat and 95.2 ± 5.6 kPa for dark meat, where meat treatment made the darker area harder.

How does creep differ between tissue regions?

Creep depth was 20.1 µm for fat, 14.0 µm for light meat and 9.3 µm for dark meat, and the fat and light meat continued to creep at a higher rate than the dark meat after 60 seconds.

What else can be measured on soft biomaterials?

On the same system: loss and storage modulus by dynamic mechanical analysis, creep, scratch resistance, fatigue by multi-cycle loading, and yield strength with a flat cylindrical diamond tip, at various temperatures and under liquids, with loads up to 400 N.

Which NANOVEA instrument was used for tissue nanoindentation?

A NANOVEA mechanical tester in nanoindentation mode, whose load cell in closed loop with the piezo table measures hard or soft gel materials from 1 to 5 kPa.

Need Reliable Soft Biomaterial Testing?