Application Note | Coin Surface Analysis

3D Surface Analysis of a Penny with Profilometry

Dimensional Analysis and Surface Subtraction of Five Pennies Minted in Different Years

Pile of copper pennies

Research & Experimental Testing

NANOVEA Laboratory

Visual Design & Editorial

Andrew Shore

Introduction

Currency is highly valued in modern society because it is traded for goods and services. Coin and paper bill currency circulates around the hands of many people. Constant transfer of physical currency creates surface deformation. NANOVEA’s 3D Profilometer scans the topography of coins minted in different years to investigate surface differences.

Why Non-Contact Profilometry Matters for Coins

Coin features are easily recognizable to the general public since they are common objects. A penny is ideal for introducing the strength of NANOVEA’s Advanced Surface Analysis Software: Mountains 3D. Surface data collected with our 3D Profilometer allows for high level analyses on complex geometry with surface subtraction and 2D contour extraction. Surface subtraction with a controlled mask, stamp, or mold compares the quality of manufacturing processes while contour extraction identifies tolerances with dimensional analysis. NANOVEA’s 3D Profilometer and Mountains 3D software investigates the submicron topography of seemingly simple objects, like pennies.

Measurement Objective

The full upper surface of five pennies were scanned using NANOVEA’s High-Speed Line Sensor. The inner and outer radius of each penny was measured using Mountains Advanced Analysis Software. An extraction from each penny surface at an area of interest with direct surface subtraction quantified surface deformation.

NANOVEA ST500 Large Area

Optical 3D Profilometer

NANOVEA ST500 large area optical profilometer for non-contact 3D surface measurement

Measurement Setup

Penny on the stage under the NANOVEA high-speed line sensor
Measurement setupValue
InstrumentNANOVEA HS2000L
Optical sensorLS2 lens (1 mm Z-range)
Scan size20 mm × 20 mm
Step size10 µm × 10 µm
Scan time00:00:24 (h:m:s)

A penny being analyzed with the NANOVEA 3D profilometer, and the measurement setup.

Results and Discussion

3D Surface

The NANOVEA HS2000 profilometer took only 24 seconds to scan 4 million points in a 20 mm x 20 mm area with a 10 µm x 10 µm step size to acquire the surface of a penny. Below is a height map and 3D visualization of the scan. The 3D view shows the High-Speed sensor’s ability to pick up small details unperceivable to the eye. Many small scratches are visible across the surface of the penny. Texture and roughness of the coin seen in the 3D view are investigated.

False-color height map of the 1995 penny over 20 mm with its ISO 25178 height parameters
Fig. 1: False color view and height parameters for the 1995 penny.
ISO 25178 height parameterValue
Sa33.492 µm
Sq44.600 µm
Ssk1.3685
Sku4.9175
Sp161.21 µm
Sv142.63 µm
Sz303.84 µm

Table 1: Height parameters of the 1995 penny.

2D profile extracted across the 1995 penny with its ISO 4287 roughness parameters
Fig. 2: 2D profile extraction and roughness parameters for the 1995 penny.
ISO 4287 parameter (Gaussian filter, 0.8 mm)Value
Ra12.47 µm
Rq13.85 µm
Rz44.37 µm
Rp22.47 µm
Rv21.90 µm
Rt54.33 µm
Rc41.64 µm

Table 2: Profile roughness parameters for the 1995 penny (Rc per ISO 4287 without amendment 2).

3D view of the 1995 penny, height amplified 10%
(a) 1995 penny, amplified 10%.
Isometric 3D view of the 1969 penny, height amplified 10%
(b) 1969 penny, amplified 10%, isometric view.

Fig. 3: 3D views of the pennies.

Dimensional Analysis

The contours of the penny were extracted and dimensional analysis obtained inner and outer diameters of the edge feature. The outer radius averaged 9.500 mm ± 0.024 while the inner radius averaged 8.960 mm ± 0.032. Additional dimensional analyses Mountains 3D can do on 2D and 3D data sources are distance measurements, step height, planarity, and angle calculations.

Contour analysis of the 1969 penny with the outer radius of 9.476 mm and inner radius of 8.961 mm
Fig. 4: Contour analysis for the 1969 penny.
YearOuter radius (mm)Inner radius (mm)
19699.4768.961
19779.4848.948
19859.4888.966
19959.5408.913
20079.5149.011
Average9.5008.960
Standard deviation0.0240.032

Table 3: Outer and inner radius of the five pennies.

Surface Subtraction

Fig. 5 shows the area of interest for the surface subtraction analysis. The 2007 penny was used as the reference surface for the four older pennies. Surface subtraction from the 2007 penny surface shows differences between pennies with holes/peaks. Total surface volume difference is obtained from adding volumes of the holes/peaks. The RMS error refers to how closely penny surfaces agree with each other.

Extracted E PLURIBUS UNUM area of the 2007 penny used as the reference surface
Fig. 5: Extracted area and reference surface for the 2007 penny.
Hole and peak maps of the E PLURIBUS UNUM area for the 1969, 1977, 1985 and 1995 pennies after subtracting the 2007 reference
Fig. 6: Surface subtraction against the 2007 penny: volume of hole/peak analysis.
Penny yearSurface volume difference (µm³)RMS value
1969258624535.405
1977391731348.182
1985474272477.598
1995181949864.756

Table 4: Surface subtraction results against the 2007 reference penny.

Conclusion

NANOVEA’s High-Speed HS2000L scanned five pennies minted in different years. Mountains 3D software compared surfaces of each coin using contour extraction, dimensional analysis, and surface subtraction. The analysis clearly defines the inner and outer radius between the pennies while directly comparing surface feature differences. With NANOVEA’s 3D profilometer’s ability to measure any surfaces with nanometer-level resolution, combined with Mountains 3D analysis capabilities, the possible Research and Quality Control applications are endless.

Frequently Asked Questions About 3D Surface Analysis of Coins

Why measure coins with a 3D profilometer?

Coins circulate through many hands, and constant handling creates surface deformation. A 3D profilometer scans the topography of coins minted in different years to investigate surface differences, and the same methods compare stamped or molded parts against a reference in manufacturing.

How fast is a high-speed 3D scan of a penny?

The NANOVEA HS2000 took only 24 seconds to scan 4 million points over a 20 mm × 20 mm area at a 10 µm × 10 µm step, revealing small scratches not perceivable to the eye.

What is surface subtraction?

An area of interest is extracted from each surface and the reference surface is subtracted from it. The volumes of the resulting holes and peaks give the total surface volume difference, and the RMS value shows how closely the surfaces agree. With a controlled mask, stamp or mold as reference, this compares manufacturing quality.

What did the surface subtraction of the pennies show?

Against the 2007 penny, the 1995 penny agreed most closely (18194986 µm³, RMS 4.756), while the 1985 penny differed most in volume (47427247 µm³, RMS 7.598) and the 1977 penny had the highest RMS (8.182).

How are the rim radii measured?

Contours are extracted from the scan and dimensional analysis measures the inner and outer radius of the edge feature. Across five pennies the outer radius averaged 9.500 ± 0.024 mm and the inner radius 8.960 ± 0.032 mm.

Which software analyzes the 3D data?

NANOVEA’s advanced analysis software, Mountains 3D, for contour extraction, dimensional analysis (distance, step height, planarity, angle), roughness and surface subtraction on 2D and 3D data.

Need Reliable 3D Surface Comparison?