Application Note | High Temperature Scratch Hardness

High Temperature Scratch Hardness of Teflon Using a Tribometer

Measuring Scratch Hardness per ASTM G171 from Room Temperature to 300°C

Rail bogie with brake discs and suspension components

Research & Experimental Testing

Duanjie Li

Visual Design & Editorial

Andrew Shore

Introduction

Hardness measures the resistance of materials to permanent or plastic deformation. Originally developed by a German mineralogist Friedrich Mohs in 1820, scratch hardness test determines the hardness of a material to scratches and abrasion due to friction from a sharp object[1]. The Mohs’ scale is a comparative index rather than a linear scale, therefore a more accurate and quantitative scratch hardness measurement was developed as described in ASTM standard G171-03[2]. It measures the average width of the scratch created by a diamond stylus and calculates the scratch hardness number (HSP).

Why Scratch Hardness Must Be Measured at High Temperatures

Materials are selected based on the service requirements. For applications involving significant temperature changes and thermal gradients, it is critical to investigate the mechanical properties of materials at high temperatures to be fully aware of the mechanical limits. Materials, especially polymers, usually soften at high temperatures. A lot of mechanical failures are caused by creep deformation and thermal fatigue taking place only at elevated temperatures. Therefore, a reliable technique for measuring hardness at high temperatures is needed to ensure proper selection of the materials for high temperature applications.

Measurement Objective

In this study, the NANOVEA T50 Tribometer measures scratch hardness of a Teflon sample at different temperatures from room temperature to 300°C.

The capability of performing high temperature scratch hardness measurement makes the NANOVEA Tribometer a versatile system for tribological and mechanical evaluations of materials for high temperature applications.

NANOVEA T50 Compact

Free Weight Tribometer

NANOVEA T50 free weight tribometer for friction and wear testing

Test Conditions

The NANOVEA T50 Free Weight Standard Tribometer was used to perform the scratch hardness tests on a Teflon sample at temperatures ranging from room temperature (RT) to 300°C. Teflon has a melting point of 326.8°C. A conical diamond stylus of apex angle 120° with tip radius of 200 µm was used.

The Teflon sample was fixed on the rotative sample stage with a distance of 10 mm to the stage center. The sample was heated up by an oven and tested at temperatures of RT, 50°C, 100°C, 150°C, 200°C, 250°C and 300°C.

ParameterValue
Normal force2 N
Sliding speed1 mm/s
Sliding distance8 mm per temperature
AtmosphereAir
TemperatureRT, 50°C, 100°C, 150°C, 200°C, 250°C, 300°C

Test parameters of the high temperature scratch hardness measurement.

Conical diamond stylus holder above the Teflon sample on the rotative stage, inside the high temperature oven of the NANOVEA T50 tribometer
High temperature scratch hardness test setup on the NANOVEA T50 Tribometer.

Results and Discussion

The scratch track profiles of the Teflon sample at different temperatures are shown in Fig. 1 in order to compare the scratch hardness at different elevated temperatures. The material pile-up on the scratch track edges forms as the stylus travels at a constant load of 2 N and ploughs into the Teflon sample, pushing and deforming the material in the scratch track to the side.

Cross-section profiles of the scratch tracks on Teflon from room temperature to 300 °C, becoming wider and deeper as temperature rises
Fig. 1: Scratch track profiles after the scratch hardness tests at different temperatures.

The scratch tracks were examined under the optical microscope as shown in Fig. 2. The measured scratch track widths and calculated scratch hardness numbers (HSP) are summarized and compared in Fig. 3. The scratch track width measured by the microscope is in agreement with that measured using the NANOVEA Profiler – the Teflon sample exhibits a wider scratch width at higher temperatures. Its scratch track width increases from 281 to 539 µm as the temperature elevates from RT to 300°C, resulting in decreased HSP from 65 to 18 MPa.

Microscope image of the scratch track on Teflon at room temperature, with the track width marked
Microscope image of the scratch track on Teflon at 50 °C, with the track width marked
Microscope image of the scratch track on Teflon at 100 °C, with the track width marked
Microscope image of the scratch track on Teflon at 150 °C, with the track width marked
Microscope image of the scratch track on Teflon at 200 °C, with the track width marked
Microscope image of the scratch track on Teflon at 250 °C, with the track width marked
Microscope image of the scratch track on Teflon at 300 °C, with the track width marked

Fig. 2: Scratch tracks under the microscope after the measurements at different temperatures.

Graph of scratch track width rising and scratch hardness HSp falling as temperature increases from room temperature to 300 °C
Fig. 3: Evolution of the scratch track width and scratch hardness vs. the temperature.

The scratch hardness at elevated temperatures can be measured with high precision and repeatability using the NANOVEA T50 Tribometer. It provides an alternative solution from other hardness measurements and makes NANOVEA Tribometers a more complete system for comprehensive high-temperature tribo-mechanical evaluations.

Conclusion

In this study, we showcase how the NANOVEA Tribometer measures the scratch hardness at elevated temperatures in compliance to ASTM G171-03. The scratch hardness test at a constant load provides an alternative simple solution for comparing the hardness of materials using the tribometer. The capacity of performing scratch hardness measurements at elevated temperatures makes the NANOVEA Tribometer an ideal tool for evaluating the high temperature tribo-mechanical properties of materials.

The NANOVEA Tribometer also offers precise and repeatable wear and friction testing using ISO and ASTM compliant rotative and linear modes, with optional high temperature wear, lubrication and tribo-corrosion modules available in one pre-integrated system. Optional 3D non-contact profiler is available for high resolution 3D imaging of wear tracks in addition to other surface measurements such as roughness.

References

[1] Wredenberg, Fredrik; PL Larsson (2009). “Scratch testing of metals and polymers: Experiments and numerics”. Wear 266 (1–2): 76
[2] ASTM G171-03 (2009), “Standard Test Method for Scratch Hardness of Materials Using a Diamond Stylus”

Frequently Asked Questions About High Temperature Scratch Hardness Testing

What is scratch hardness, and how is it measured?

Scratch hardness is the resistance of a material to scratches and abrasion from a sharp object. ASTM G171 measures it quantitatively: a diamond stylus scratches the surface under a constant load, the average width of the scratch is measured, and the scratch hardness number (HSp) is calculated from the load and the width.

Why measure hardness at high temperature?

Materials, especially polymers, usually soften at high temperatures, and many mechanical failures are caused by creep deformation and thermal fatigue that occur only at elevated temperatures. Measuring hardness at the service temperature ensures proper selection of materials for applications with significant temperature changes and thermal gradients.

How much does temperature reduce the scratch hardness of Teflon?

In this study, the scratch track width of Teflon increased from 281 to 539 µm as the temperature rose from room temperature to 300°C, and the scratch hardness number decreased from 65 to 18 MPa. Teflon has a melting point of 326.8°C.

Can a tribometer measure scratch hardness?

Yes. The NANOVEA T50 tribometer performed constant-load scratch hardness tests in compliance with ASTM G171, here with a conical diamond stylus of 120° apex angle and 200 µm tip radius at 2 N. It provides a simple alternative to other hardness measurements on the same system used for wear and friction testing.

How is the scratch track width measured?

The scratch tracks were examined under an optical microscope, and the track profiles were also measured with the NANOVEA profiler. The two measurements agreed: the Teflon sample showed a wider scratch width at higher temperatures.

What else can a high temperature tribometer measure?

NANOVEA tribometers offer precise and repeatable wear and friction testing in ISO and ASTM compliant rotative and linear modes, with optional high temperature wear, lubrication and tribocorrosion modules in one pre-integrated system, and an optional 3D non-contact profiler for imaging wear tracks and measuring roughness.

Need Reliable High Temperature Hardness Testing?