Application Note | Scratch Hardness

Scratch Hardness Measurement Using Tribometer

ASTM G171 Scratch Hardness of Three Metals with the Tribometer’s Integrated Profilometer

Diamond scratch stylus on a metal specimen in a tribometer

Research & Experimental Testing

Duanjie Li

Visual Design & Editorial

Andrew Shore

Introduction

Hardness measures the resistance of materials to permanent or plastic deformation. There are three types of hardness measurements: scratch hardness, indentation hardness and rebound hardness. A scratch hardness test determines the hardness of a material to scratches and abrasion due to friction from a sharp object1. It was originally developed by the German mineralogist Friedrich Mohs in 1820, with talc assigned a value of 1 and diamond a value of 10, and is still widely applied to rank the physical properties of minerals2.

Mohs’ scale is not linear; therefore a more accurate and quantitative scratch hardness measurement was developed, as described in ASTM standard G171-033. In this scratch hardness measurement, a diamond stylus of specified geometry scratches the surface of the tested material along a path under a constant normal force at a constant speed. The average width of the scratch is measured and used to calculate the scratch hardness number (HSP). This technique provides a simple solution for scaling the hardness of different materials, including metals, ceramics, polymers and coated surfaces.

Why Measure Scratch Hardness on a Tribometer

Running the scratch hardness test on the tribometer that already performs wear and friction testing, with its integrated profilometer measuring the track, gives a hardness value and the in-situ friction from a single system.

ℹ️ Learn more about friction and wear testing lab services.

Measurement Objective

In this study, the NANOVEA Tribometer is used to measure the scratch hardness of different metals. The capacity of performing scratch hardness measurements with high precision and reproducibility makes the NANOVEA Tribometer a more complete system for tribological and mechanical evaluations.

NANOVEA T2000 High Load

Pneumatic Tribometer

NANOVEA T2000 high load pneumatic tribometer
Conical diamond stylus held against a polished metal specimen on the rotative stage
Fig. 1: Scratch stylus on the test specimen.

Test Conditions

The NANOVEA Tribometer was employed to perform the scratch hardness tests on three polished metals (Al6061, Cu110 and SS304). A conical diamond stylus with an apex angle of 120° and a tip radius of 200 µm was used. The scratch test was performed on the sample fixed on the rotative sample stage at a large distance of 3 cm from the stage center, in order to ensure local linearity of the scratch track for accurate track width measurement. Each sample was tested with three scratches under the same parameters to ensure reproducibility of the results. The test parameters are summarized in Table 1. A scratch track profile scan was performed after the scratch test using the integrated non-contact optical profilometer.

Test parameterValue
Normal force10 N
Sliding speed20 mm/min
Sliding distance10 mm
AtmosphereAir
Temperature24 °C (room)

Table 1: Test parameters of the scratch hardness measurement.

Results and Discussion

The scratch track profiles of the three metals (Al6061, Cu110 and SS304) measured by the integrated non-contact optical profilometer are shown in Fig. 2 in order to compare the scratch hardness of different materials. The pile-ups at the sides of the scratch tracks form as the stylus travels at a constant load of 10 N and ploughs into the metal, pushing and deforming the metal in the scratch track to the side. The track width used for the calculation of scratch hardness can be determined using the peaks of the two pile-ups.

Cross-section profiles of the scratch tracks in Al6061, Cu110 and SS304 with pile-ups at both sides, SS304 narrowest and shallowest
Fig. 2: Scratch track profiles after the scratch hardness tests.

The images of the scratch tracks after the tests by the tribometer were examined under the optical microscope, as shown in Fig. 3. The scratch tracks created using the NANOVEA Mechanical Tester are displayed for comparison. The measured scratch track width and calculated scratch hardness number (HSP) are summarized and compared in Table 2. The metals show different scratch track widths of 170, 228 and 92 µm for Al6061, Cu110 and SS304, respectively, resulting in calculated HSP values of 0.88, 0.49 and 3.01 GPa. The scratch track width measured by the microscope is in agreement with that measured by the profilometer on the tribometer. The scratch tracks created by the tribometer and the mechanical tester exhibit comparable widths, which in turn result in close calculated HSP values.

Paired micrographs of the scratch tracks in each metal made by the tribometer and by the mechanical tester, with widths marked
Fig. 3: Scratch tracks under the microscope after the measurements (100X): (a) Al6061, (b) Cu110 and (c) SS304, by the tribometer (left) and the mechanical tester (right).
MetalTribometer: track width (µm)Tribometer: HSP (GPa)Mechanical tester: track width (µm)Mechanical tester: HSP (GPa)
Al6061170 ± 60.88174 ± 110.84
Cu110228 ± 80.49220 ± 10.52
SS30492 ± 43.0189 ± 53.20

Table 2: Summary of scratch track width and scratch hardness number.

In addition to the scratch hardness computed from the scratch track width, the evolution of the coefficient of friction (COF) was recorded in situ during the scratch hardness test, as shown in Fig. 4. Such information provides insight into mechanical failures that might take place during scratching, enabling users to detect mechanical defects and further investigate the scratch behavior of the tested material.

The scratch hardness tests can be finished within a couple of minutes with good precision and repeatability using the single NANOVEA Tribometer equipped with the integrated profilometer. The scratch hardness test in this study provides an alternative solution for hardness measurement and makes the NANOVEA Tribometer a more complete system for comprehensive tribo-mechanical evaluation.

Coefficient of friction over the 10 mm scratch for the three metals, Cu110 highest
Fig. 4: The evolution of coefficient of friction during the scratch hardness tests.

Conclusion

In this study, we showcased the capacity of the NANOVEA Tribometer in performing scratch hardness tests in compliance with ASTM G171-03. The scratch hardness test at a constant load provides an alternative simple solution for comparing the hardness of materials using a tribometer equipped with a profilometer. Compared to conventional Mohs scratch hardness tests, the NANOVEA Tribometer can accurately measure a quantitative hardness value and monitor the evolution of the coefficient of friction in situ.

NANOVEA Tribometers also offer precise and repeatable wear and friction testing using ISO and ASTM compliant rotative and linear modes, with optional high temperature wear, lubrication and tribo-corrosion modules available in one pre-integrated system. An optional 3D non-contact profiler is available for high resolution 3D imaging of the wear track in addition to other surface measurements such as roughness.

References

1. Wredenberg, F.; Larsson, P. L. (2009), Scratch testing of metals and polymers: Experiments and numerics, Wear 266 (1–2): 76.
2. Mohs hardness, Encyclopædia Britannica Online, 2009.
3. ASTM G171-03(2009), Standard Test Method for Scratch Hardness of Materials Using a Diamond Stylus.

Frequently Asked Questions About Scratch Hardness

What is scratch hardness?

The resistance of a material to scratches and abrasion from a sharp object. Mohs’ scale ranks it qualitatively; ASTM G171 makes it quantitative by scratching with a diamond stylus at constant load and speed and calculating the scratch hardness number HSP from the average track width.

Can a tribometer measure scratch hardness?

Yes. Here a conical diamond stylus (120°, 200 µm tip radius) scratched each metal at 10 N and 20 mm/min over 10 mm, and the integrated non-contact profilometer measured the track width.

What were the results?

Track widths of 170, 228 and 92 µm gave HSP of 0.88, 0.49 and 3.01 GPa for Al6061, Cu110 and SS304.

Do the results agree with a mechanical tester?

Yes. The mechanical tester gave widths of 174, 220 and 89 µm and HSP of 0.84, 0.52 and 3.20 GPa, close to the tribometer values.

How is the track width determined?

From the peaks of the two pile-ups at the sides of the scratch in the profilometer scan; microscope measurements agreed with the profilometer.

Why record friction during the scratch?

The in-situ COF gives insight into mechanical failures that might occur during scratching, helping detect defects and study the scratch behavior.

Need Hardness and Wear Data from One System?