Application Note | Coating Scratch Resistance
Scratch Adhesion Testing of Disc Coatings
Critical Loads and Failure Modes of CD and Blu-ray Protective Coatings

Research & Experimental Testing
Duanjie Li
Visual Design & Editorial
Andrew Shore
Introduction
Compact disc (CD) and Blu-ray disc (BD) are optical discs used to store music, video and data by writing data as pits in a reflective layer. The plastic disc is composed of polycarbonate and a thin metal layer. Optical discs are susceptible to damage during handling and from environmental exposure.
Importance of Scratch Testing for Optical Disc Coatings
With the same physical dimension, the BD possesses a substantially higher storage capacity of 25 GB per layer, compared to 700 MB for CD. Such an increased capacity for BD was achieved by the employment of advanced techniques such as applying a blue-violet laser, increasing the numerical aperture of the objective lens, making the optical beam pass through a thinner cover layer, etc. This leads to a different layer architecture between BD and CD, as displayed in Fig. 11. BD has a much thinner cover layer of ~0.1 mm, compared to ~1.1 mm for CD. Since the BD data layer is closer to the clear side of the disc, it is more vulnerable to scratches. Therefore, the testing of scratch resistance is required by the Blu-ray Disc specification, and hard coating technology is developed to produce strong scratch-protection coatings. A reliable and repeatable technique to quantitatively assess and compare the scratch resistance of different coatings becomes vital for the R&D and quality control of protective optical coatings.
ℹ️ Learn more about scratch testing lab services.

Measurement Objective
In this study, instrumented scratch testing is used to assess the failure modes of the top layers of CD and BD. This test allows users to quantitatively compare the scratch resistance of different protective coatings.

Test Parameters
The NANOVEA Mechanical Tester was used to perform the scratch tests on the CD and BD coatings using the same test parameters, as summarized in Table 1. Since the data layer is closer to the label side of the CD and the clear side of the BD, which have a comparable thickness of 0.1 mm, it is more vulnerable to scratches on these sides. As a result, the scratch resistance of the label side of the CD and the clear side of the BD is compared in this study. For detailed coating thickness measurement of the CD and BD cover layers, refer to the application note Transparent Film Thickness by 3D Non-Contact Profilometry.
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Loading mode | Progressive (linear) |
| Initial load | 0.1 N |
| Final load | 20 N |
| Loading rate | 20 N/min |
| Scratch speed | 8 mm/min |
| Scratch length | 8 mm |
| Indenter material | Diamond |
| Indenter type | Sphero-conical |
| Indenter radius | 200 µm |
Table 1: Test parameters of the scratch tests on CD and BD.
Results and Discussion
Fig. 3 shows the evolution of the coefficient of friction (COF) and depth of the CD and BD as a function of the normal load of the stylus during the scratch tests. It can be observed that the stylus penetrates substantially faster and deeper into the CD than the BD. The final depth of the CD and BD at a load of 20 N is ~290 and ~130 µm, respectively. The CD has a higher COF than the BD throughout the scratch test.

Fig. 4 compares the panorama of the scratch track on the CD and BD, and Fig. 5 displays the cohesive or adhesive failures appearing at certain critical loads, Lc, which is defined as the lowest load at which a recognizable failure occurs. The CD exhibits much more severe damage in the coating compared to the BD. The indenter initially creates plastic deformation and leaves permanent marks on the coating at a load of 0.01 and 0.86 N, respectively, for the CD and BD. As the load progressively increases to 3.08 N, delamination of the coating starts to take place on the CD surface. The stylus reaches the recording layer and creates permanent damage to the data. This is correlated with the fast increase of the COF before the normal load of 3.08 N and the noticeable oscillation of the COF thereafter. The coating has been completely removed at the end of the scratch test, where the stylus penetrates to a depth of 0.286 mm. In comparison, the BD coating shows the first sign of cohesive cracking at a load of 5.91 N, followed by periodic occurrence of such cracks. However, the coating maintains its adhesion to the substrate underneath throughout the test. It exhibits no sign of delamination until the end of the test, where the load of 20 N creates a penetration depth of 0.128 mm.


Such quantitative analysis of the COF, penetration depth and critical loads of the scratch track provides users a reliable and repeatable tool to assess the scratch resistance, as well as the cohesive and adhesive strength, of protective coatings.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the NANOVEA Mechanical Tester measures scratch resistance in a controlled and closely monitored fashion and uses critical loads as a quantitative value for comparing the cohesive and adhesive strength of different protective coatings. The BD cover layer in this study shows a significantly enhanced scratch resistance compared to the CD.
The Nano, Micro or Macro modules of the NANOVEA Mechanical Tester all include ISO and ASTM compliant indentation, scratch and wear tester modes, providing the widest and most user friendly range of testing available in a single system.
References
1. Blu-ray Disc, Wikipedia, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blu-ray_Disc.
Frequently Asked Questions About Disc Coating Scratch Testing
Why does Blu-ray need a scratch-resistant coating?
A Blu-ray disc has a cover layer of only ~0.1 mm over its data layer, against ~1.1 mm for a CD, so the data sits close to the clear side and is more vulnerable; the Blu-ray Disc specification therefore requires scratch-resistance testing and hard coatings.
Which sides were tested?
The label side of the CD and the clear side of the BD, where the data layer lies under a comparable thickness of about 0.1 mm.
How was the scratch test run?
A progressive load from 0.1 to 20 N at 20 N/min over 8 mm with a 200 µm sphero-conical diamond stylus, using the same parameters on both discs.
When did the coatings fail?
The CD showed permanent marks at 0.01 N and coating delamination from 3.08 N, damaging the recording layer; the BD showed permanent marks at 0.86 N and its first cohesive crack at 5.91 N, with no delamination up to 20 N.
How deep did the stylus go?
At 20 N the stylus reached 0.286 mm in the CD and 0.128 mm in the BD; the CD also had a higher COF throughout the test.
What does a critical load mean?
The critical load, Lc, is the lowest load at which a recognizable failure occurs; it is used as a quantitative value to compare cohesive and adhesive strength of coatings.



