Application Note | Flooring Wear Testing

Flooring Wear Testing: Progressive Wear Mapping of Wood and Stone Flooring

Tracking Wear Rate and Friction Cycle by Cycle with a Tribometer and Integrated 3D Profilometer

Hands placing a ceramic floor tile onto trowelled adhesive

Research & Experimental Testing

Frank Liu

Visual Design & Editorial

Andrew Shore

Introduction

Flooring materials are designed to be durable, but they often suffer wear and tear from everyday activities such as movement and furniture use. To ensure their longevity, most types of flooring have a protective wear layer that resists damage. However, the thickness and durability of the wear layer vary depending on the flooring type and level of foot traffic. In addition, different layers within the flooring structure, such as UV coatings, decorative layers, and glaze, have varying wear rates.

That’s where progressive wear mapping comes in. Using the NANOVEA T2000 Tribometer with an integrated 3D Non-Contact Profilometer, precise monitoring and analysis of the performance and longevity of flooring materials can be done. By providing detailed insight into the wear behavior of various flooring materials, scientists and technical professionals can make more informed decisions when selecting and designing new flooring systems.

Why Progressive Wear Mapping Matters for Flooring Wear Testing

Flooring testing has traditionally centered on the wear rate of a sample to determine its durability against wear. However, progressive wear mapping allows analyzing the sample’s wear rate throughout the test, providing valuable insights into its wear behavior. This in-depth analysis allows for correlations between friction data and wear rate, which can identify the root causes of wear. It should be noted that wear rates are not constant throughout wear tests. Thus, observing the progression of wear gives a more accurate assessment of the sample’s wear. Progressing beyond traditional testing methods, the adoption of progressive wear mapping has contributed to significant advancements in the field of flooring testing.

The NANOVEA T2000 Tribometer with an integrated 3D Non-Contact Profilometer is a groundbreaking solution for wear testing and volume loss measurements. Its ability to move with precision between the pin and the profilometer guarantees the reliability of results by eliminating any deviation in wear track radius or location. But that’s not all – the 3D Non-Contact Profilometer’s advanced capabilities allow for high-speed surface measurements, reducing scanning time to mere seconds. With the capability of applying loads of up to 2,000 N and achieving spinning speeds of up to 5,000 rpm, the NANOVEA T2000 Tribometer offers versatility and precision in the evaluation process. It’s clear that this equipment holds a vital role in progressive wear mapping.

Wood flooring sample clamped under a ring fixture on the NANOVEA T2000 tribometer before wear testing
Integrated 3D non-contact profilometer scanning the wear track on the flooring sample after a wear test

Fig. 1: Sample set-up prior to wear testing (left) and post-wear test profilometry of the wear track (right).

Measurement Objective

Progressive wear mapping testing was performed on two types of flooring materials: stone and wood. Each sample underwent a total of 7 test cycles, with increasing test durations of 2, 4, 8, 20, 40, 60, and 120 s, allowing for a comparison of wear over time.

After each test cycle, the wear track was profiled using the NANOVEA 3D Non-Contact Profilometer. From the data collected by the profiler, the volume of the hole and wear rate can be analyzed using the integrated features in the NANOVEA Tribometer software or our surface analysis software, Mountains.

NANOVEA T2000 High Load

Pneumatic Tribometer

NANOVEA T2000 High Load Pneumatic Tribometer

Samples and Test Parameters

Wood flooring panel and a stone flooring piece used as wear mapping samples, each with circular wear tracks
Wood and stone flooring samples used for progressive wear mapping.
ParameterValue
Load40 N
Test durationvaries
Speed200 rpm
Radius10 mm
Distancevaries
Ball materialTungsten Carbide
Ball diameter10 mm

Wear mapping test parameters.

Test durations used over the 7 cycles were 2, 4, 8, 20, 40, 60, and 120 seconds, respectively. The distances traveled were 0.40, 0.81, 1.66, 4.16, 8.36, 12.55, and 25.11 meters.

Wear Mapping Results

Wood Flooring

Test CycleMax COFMin COFAvg. COF
10.3350.1240.275
20.3370.2070.295
30.3800.2290.329
40.3930.2650.354
50.3520.2050.314
60.3450.1990.312
70.3150.2110.293

Table 1: Coefficient of friction of the wood flooring for each test cycle.

Radial orientation
Test cycleTotal volume loss (µm³)Total distance traveled (m)Wear rate (mm³/N·m) ×10⁻⁵Instantaneous wear rate (mm³/N·m) ×10⁻⁵
12962476870.401833.7461833.746
23552452271.221093.260181.5637
35963713262.88898.242363.1791
48837477677.04530.629172.5496
5120717995115.40360.88996.69074
6147274531827.95293.32952.89311
7185131921053.06184.34337.69599

Table 2: Wood flooring volume loss, distance, wear rate and instantaneous wear rate per test cycle (radial orientation).

Wood flooring wear rate versus total distance traveled, falling steeply after the first cycle and leveling off
Wood flooring instantaneous wear rate versus test cycle, highest at cycle 1 and low thereafter

Fig. 2: Wear rate vs total distance traveled (left) and instantaneous wear rate vs test cycle (right) for wood flooring.

Coefficient of friction graph for test 7 on wood flooring, steady through the test
3D view of the circular wear track on wood flooring after test 7

Fig. 3: COF graph and 3D view of the wear track from test #7 on wood flooring.

Extracted profiles across the wood flooring wear track from test 7 with width and depth parameters
Wood flooring wear track profile from test 7 with maximum depth, area of the hole, maximum height and area of the peak
Overlaid cross-section profiles of the wood flooring wear track

Fig. 4: Cross-sectional analysis of the wood wear track from test #7.

Volume and area analysis map of the wood flooring wear track from test 7 with projected area and void and material volumes

Fig. 5: Volume and area analysis of the wear track on wood sample test #7.

For full result details, watch the wood flooring wear mapping video.

Stone Flooring

Test CycleMax COFMin COFAvg. COF
10.2490.0350.186
20.3490.1970.275
30.2940.1540.221
40.5030.1240.273
50.5480.1060.390
60.5100.1290.434
70.5270.1810.472

Table 3: Coefficient of friction of the stone flooring for each test cycle.

Radial orientation
Test cycleTotal volume loss (µm³)Total distance traveled (m)Wear rate (mm³/N·m) ×10⁻⁵Instantaneous wear rate (mm³/N·m) ×10⁻⁵
1962788460.40595.957595.9573
28042897311.222475.1852178.889
313161478552.881982.355770.9501
431365302157.041883.2691093.013
51082173218015.403235.1802297.508
62017496034327.954018.2821862.899
74251206342053.064233.0812224.187

Table 4: Stone flooring volume loss, distance, wear rate and instantaneous wear rate per test cycle (radial orientation).

Stone flooring wear rate versus total distance traveled, rising over the cycles
Stone flooring instantaneous wear rate versus test cycle, varying strongly between cycles

Fig. 6: Wear rate vs total distance traveled (left) and instantaneous wear rate vs test cycle (right) for stone flooring.

Coefficient of friction graph for test 7 on stone flooring
3D view of the deep circular wear track on stone flooring after test 7

Fig. 7: COF graph and 3D view of the wear track from test #7 on stone flooring.

Extracted profiles across the stone flooring wear track from test 7 with width and depth parameters
Stone flooring wear track profile from test 7 with maximum depth, area of the hole, maximum height and area of the peak
Overlaid cross-section profiles of the stone flooring wear track

Fig. 8: Cross-sectional analysis of the stone wear track from test #7.

Volume and area analysis map of the stone flooring wear track from test 7 with projected area and void and material volumes

Fig. 9: Volume and area analysis of the wear track on stone sample test #7.

Discussion

The instantaneous wear rate is calculated with the following equation:

ΔV / (N·ΔX) = (Vn − Vn−1) / (N·(Xn − Xn−1))

Where V is the volume of a hole, N is the load, and X is the total distance, this equation describes the wear rate between test cycles. The instantaneous wear rate can be used to better identify changes in wear rate throughout the test.

Both samples have very different wear behaviors. Over time, the wood flooring starts with a high wear rate but quickly drops to a smaller, steady value. For the stone flooring, the wear rate appears to start at a low value and trends to a higher value over cycles. The instantaneous wear rate also shows little consistency. The specific reason for the difference is not certain but may be due to the structure of the samples. The stone flooring seems to consist of loose grain-like particles, which would wear differently compared to the wood’s compact structure. Additional testing and research would be needed to ascertain the cause of this wear behavior.

The data from the coefficient of friction (COF) seems to agree with the observed wear behavior. The COF graph for the wood flooring appears consistent throughout the cycles, complementing its steady wear rate. For the stone flooring, the average COF increases throughout the cycles, similar to how the wear rate also increases with cycles. There are also apparent changes in the shape of the friction graphs, suggesting changes in how the ball is interacting with the stone sample. This is most apparent in cycle 2 and cycle 4.

Conclusion

The NANOVEA T2000 Tribometer showcases its ability to perform progressive wear mapping by analyzing the wear rate between two different flooring samples. Pausing the continuous wear test and scanning the surface with the NANOVEA 3D Non-Contact Profilometer provides valuable insights into the material’s wear behavior over time.

The NANOVEA T2000 Tribometer with the integrated 3D Non-Contact Profilometer provides a wide variety of data, including COF (Coefficient of Friction) data, surface measurements, depth readings, surface visualization, volume loss, wear rate, and more. This comprehensive set of information allows users to gain a deeper understanding of the interactions between the system and the sample. With its controlled loading, high precision, ease of use, high loading, wide speed range, and additional environmental modules, the NANOVEA T2000 Tribometer takes tribology to the next level.

Frequently Asked Questions About Flooring Wear Testing

What is progressive wear mapping?

Progressive wear mapping pauses a wear test at set intervals and profiles the wear track each time, so the wear rate can be analyzed throughout the test instead of only at the end. Because wear rates are not constant during a wear test, observing the progression of wear gives a more accurate assessment of a sample and allows friction data to be correlated with wear rate.

How is the wear resistance of flooring tested with a tribometer?

A loaded ball slides over the flooring sample in a circular track while friction is recorded, and the worn volume is measured afterwards. In this study, a 10 mm tungsten carbide ball was loaded at 40 N on a 10 mm radius at 200 rpm, over seven test cycles of 2, 4, 8, 20, 40, 60 and 120 s, with the wear track profiled after each cycle.

What is the instantaneous wear rate?

It is the wear rate between two test cycles: the change in worn volume divided by the load and the distance traveled between those cycles, ΔV/(NΔX) = (Vₙ − Vₙ₋₁)/(N(Xₙ − Xₙ₋₁)). Unlike the cumulative wear rate, it shows changes in wear behavior during the test.

How did wood and stone flooring differ in wear behavior?

Very differently. The wood flooring started with a high wear rate that quickly dropped to a smaller, steady value, falling from 1833.746 to 184.343 × 10⁻⁵ mm³/N·m over the seven cycles. The stone flooring started low and trended higher, rising from 595.957 to 4233.081 × 10⁻⁵ mm³/N·m, possibly because it consists of loose grain-like particles.

Why integrate a 3D profilometer into the tribometer?

The NANOVEA T2000 moves with precision between the pin and the profilometer, which eliminates any deviation in wear track radius or location between test cycles. The 3D non-contact profilometer scans the wear track in seconds, so the test can be paused, measured and resumed without removing the sample.

What data does a tribometer with an integrated profilometer provide?

Coefficient of friction, surface measurements, depth readings, surface visualization, volume loss and wear rate, among others. The NANOVEA T2000 applies loads of up to 2,000 N and offers a wide speed range and additional environmental modules.

Need Reliable Flooring Wear Testing?