Application Note | Lens Quality Control

Investigating the Properties of Plastic Lens

Radius of Curvature, Roughness, Thickness, Scratch Hardness, Friction and Wear of a Polycarbonate Lens

Safety eyewear with polycarbonate lenses

Research & Experimental Testing

NANOVEA Laboratory

Visual Design & Editorial

Andrew Shore

Introduction

Polycarbonate lenses are commonly used in many optical applications. Their high impact resistance, low weight, and cheap cost of high-volume production makes them more practical than traditional glass in various applications [1]. Some of these applications require safety (e.g. safety eyewear), complexity (e.g. Fresnel lens) or durability (e.g. traffic light lens) criteria that are difficult to meet without the use of plastics. Its ability to cheaply meet many requirements while maintaining sufficient optical qualities makes plastic lenses stand out in its field. Polycarbonate lenses also have limitations. The main concern for consumers is the ease at which they can be scratched. To compensate for this, extra processes can be carried out to apply an anti-scratch coating.

NANOVEA takes a look into some important properties of polycarbonate lenses by utilizing our three metrology instruments: Profilometer, Tribometer, and Mechanical Tester.

Importance of Testing Polycarbonate Lenses

Surface data of a lens is ideal for obtaining the surface roughness and radius of curvature. These properties influence the optical quality of the lens. Radius of curvature affects the lens’ optical power while surface roughness will influence the scattering of light. In addition, the thickness of the lens will be measured. Lens thickness of the lens will affect its effective focal length.

The quality of the lens will decrease as more defects are on the surface of the lens. Material with high scratch resistance tends to wear less over time and are less prone to defects caused by external sources. Scratch hardness will define the resistance of the sample to scratch defects. This can be used to determine the scratch hardness of the bulk material or effectiveness of a scratch resistant coatings. Additionally, adhesive scratch testing can be conducted to determine the quality of adhesion between the coating and the lens.

Coefficient of friction (COF) can be obtained from tribology testing against various materials. Since polycarbonate lenses are used in many different applications, it would be practical to understand how other materials will behave when interacting with the lens. Thus, friction can be minimized (or maximized) when selecting complementary materials. Wear testing demonstrates the durability of the sample in different conditions.

The testing and results found during this study is representative of how the sample will perform in real life applications. The results can be used to determine which type of material, process, or design is ideal for the user’s application. Quality control testing can also be repeatedly conducted with our highly accurate instruments.

Green bicycle signal of a traffic light with a plastic lens

Traffic light lenses must meet durability criteria that are hard to reach without plastics.

Measurement Objective

In this case study, a general investigation on several important properties of a polycarbonate lens is conducted. The following properties will be obtained from our profilometer, tribometer, and mechanical tester: surface roughness, radius of curvature, thickness, scratch hardness, COF against various materials, and wear rate.

Polycarbonate lens on a stage under the optical pen of a NANOVEA profilometer
Lens about to be tested on the NANOVEA Profilometer.
Polycarbonate lens clamped on the rotating stage of a NANOVEA tribometer
Lens about to be tested on the NANOVEA Tribometer.
Polycarbonate lens held by clamps on the stage of a NANOVEA mechanical tester
Lens about to be tested on the NANOVEA Mechanical Tester.

Profilometry: Radius of Curvature and Roughness

NANOVEA ST500 large area optical profilometer for non-contact 3D surface measurement

NANOVEA ST500 Large Area Optical 3D Profilometer

NANOVEA PS50 compact optical profilometer

NANOVEA PS50 Compact Optical Profilometer

Test parameterValue
InstrumentNANOVEA HS2000
Optical sensorL1 lens (200 µm Z-range)
Scan size10 mm x 10 mm
Step size5 µm x 5 µm
Scan time (h:m:s)00:01:02

Table 1: Test parameters for roughness and radius measurements on the lens.

The results from the profilometry measurements can be seen in Figure 1 and 2. The Figures below are 2D and 3D images of the lens’s true form.

False-color height maps of the front side, domed, and back side, dished, of the lens over 10 x 10 mm
Fig. 1: False-color view of front side (left) and back side (right) of polycarbonate lens.
3D views of the front and back side of the lens showing its true form
Fig. 2: 3-D view of front side (left) and back side (right) of polycarbonate lens; amplified 10%.

Roughness

To obtain roughness data, the form of the sample must be removed. A Gaussian filter with a nesting index of 0.25mm was applied to obtain roughness height parameters. An Sa value of 26.76nm was obtained for the front side of the polycarbonate lens, and 18.16nm for the back side of the plastic lens. Their respective Sq values were 37.77nm and 36.02nm. These values are very low and are ideal to minimize scattering of light when light interacts with the lens’s surface.

3D view of the lens front side after form removal, with ISO 25178 height parameters, Sa 0.02676 µm
Fig. 3: 3D-view and height parameters of front side of polycarbonate lens after a Gaussian filter of 0.25 mm.
3D view of the lens back side after form removal, with ISO 25178 height parameters, Sa 0.01816 µm
Fig. 4: 3D-view and height parameters of back side of polycarbonate lens after a Gaussian filter of 0.25 mm.

Radius of Curvature

Conducting an area scan on the lens ensures the radius of curvature is captured at the apex of the curve. To observe the symmetry of the lens, radius of curvature was calculated from both the X- and Y-axis. Values of 142.1 and 135.5mm were obtained for the front side and 137.0mm and 139.2mm were obtained for the back side.

Profiles extracted across the front side in X and Y with fitted radii of 142.1 and 135.5 mm
Fig. 5: Profile extraction in the X-axis (left) and Y-axis (right) of front side of polycarbonate lens.
Profiles extracted across the back side in X and Y with fitted radii of 137.0 and 139.2 mm
Fig. 6: Profile extraction in the X-axis (left) and Y-axis (right) of back side of polycarbonate lens.

Profilometry: Thickness

Test parameterValue
InstrumentNANOVEA PS50
Optical sensorPS5 (10000 µm Z-range)
Scan size5 mm x 5 mm
Step size10 µm x 10 µm
Scan time (h:m:s)00:36:32

Table 2: Test parameters for thickness measurements on the lens.

Utilizing our point sensor system, the thickness of the polycarbonate lens was obtained. This measurement works by having a focal point at each surface. Having multiple focal points are possible due to our axial chromatism technique. The difference in refraction between air and the sample is corrected using the sample’s index of refraction. The two surfaces, top and bottom, can be seen in figure 7. Since the composition of our sample is unknown, this was set to a value of common plastic: polycarbonate – 1.58. By subtracting the two surfaces scanned, the thickness can be obtained. The mean thickness of the sample, scanned near the apex of the curvature, was found to be approximately 2.611mm.

Diagram of a curved lens with its top and bottom surfaces and the thickness between them
Thickness is the distance between the top and bottom surfaces.
False-color height maps of the lens top and bottom surfaces over 5 x 5 mm
Fig. 7: False-color view of top surface (left) and bottom surface (right).
False-color thickness map of the lens with height parameters, mean 2611 µm
Fig. 8: False-color view (left) and height parameters (right) for thickness of polycarbonate.

Mechanical Testing: Scratch Hardness

NANOVEA PB1000 Large Platform

Mechanical Tester

Nanoindenter and scratch tester platform NANOVEA PB1000 with nano and micro modules
Test parameterValue
Load typeConstant
Final load15 N
Scratch length5 mm
Scratching speed18 mm/min
Indenter geometry120° cone
Indenter material (tip)Diamond
Indenter tip radius200 µm

Table 3: Parameters used for scratch hardness testing on polycarbonate lens.

The scratch test was conducted in accordance to ASTM-G171. Scratches were made at the apex of the lens to minimize error caused by the curvature of the lens.

A scratch hardness of 420.59 ± 8.69MPa was obtained. As expected, the scratch hardness value is quite low due to the nature of plastics. For reference, the scratch hardness testing we previously conducted on aluminum, copper, and steel in the past were 0.84, 0.52, and 3.20GPa respectively [2]. Even though testing conditions were different, the scratch resistance of the polycarbonate lens appears to be in the same magnitude as a soft, scratch-prone metal like copper.

Linear scratch test graph of normal force near 15 N and frictional force against scratch length
Fig. 9: Friction graph obtained from the scratch test.
Optical microscope image of the scratch on the lens with its measured width
Fig. 10: Scratch hardness measurement conducted under an optical microscope. The blue dotted lines are positioned at the edge of the scratch to obtain scratch width.
Measurement 1 (MPa)Measurement 2 (MPa)Measurement 3 (MPa)
Scratch 1432.19418.89412.52
Scratch 2431.51416.25413.4
Scratch 3431.71421.55409.8

Table 4: Results from scratch hardness test.

Scratch Imaging with Optical Profilometry

The polycarbonate lens was profiled with our profilometry instrument to closely inspect the outcome of the scratch test. A great deal of material was found to be surrounding the area where the scratch took place (Figure 13). The volume of material around the scratch (Peak) and the volume lost (Hole) are about the same. From this study, it is observed that the soft plastic seems to have been easily displaced during the scratch. This allows us to make the conclusion that the material has a low scratch resistance.

The mean depth of the scratch ended up being 7.864 ± 0.2652µm into the surface. This was obtained by extracting a series of profile across the scratched area and averaging the maximum valley depth (Pv) of each profile (Figure 14).

False-color height map of the 5 mm scratch on the lens
Fig. 11: False-color view of a scratch made on the lens.
3D view of the scratch groove and its raised edges
Fig. 12: 3-D view of scratch made on the lens.
Volume of a hole and peak analysis of the scratch with surface, volume and depth results
Fig. 13: Volume of a hole/peak analysis on the scratch created.
Series of profiles across the scratch with the mean profile, and their ISO 4287 primary profile parameters
Fig. 14: Extracted series of profiles (left) and their primary profile parameters (right). Red line indicates the mean profile.

Tribology: Coefficient of Friction

NANOVEA T50 Compact

Free Weight Tribometer

NANOVEA T50 free weight tribometer for friction and wear testing
Test parameterValue
Load0.5 N
Test duration5 min
Speed10 rpm
Radius0.0–5.0 mm
Total distance0.78 m
Pin geometryBall
Pin materialRubber, PTFE, ZrO₂, Al₂O₃, SS440C
Pin diameter6 mm

Table 5: Parameters used for coefficient of friction testing on polycarbonate lens.

CombinationDisk materialPin material
1PolycarbonateRubber
2PolycarbonatePTFE
3PolycarbonateZrO₂
4PolycarbonateAl₂O₃
5PolycarbonateSS440C

Table 6: Pin-on-disk material combinations.

A Pin-On-Disk Spiral Test was performed to ensure that the pins would pass over an unworn region throughout all tests. The first five revolutions were cropped from the graphs. This was done to remove data when the radius was near 0 (minimal tangential movement). The curvature of the lens must be kept in consideration when analyzing the COF data.

The test results rank the following material from highest COF to lowest COF: Rubber, Al₂O₃, ZrO₂, PTFE, SS440C. The tests conducted were performed with a small normal force to minimize the effects of wear on the sample.

Five COF against revolution graphs for rubber, PTFE, ZrO2, Al2O3 and SS440C balls on the lens
Fig. 15: COF graphs of 1) Rubber, 2) PTFE, 3) ZrO₂, 4) Al₂O₃, 5) SS440C.
Pin materialMax COFMin COFAverage COF
Rubber0.9470.2770.734
PTFE0.2100.0270.089
ZrO₂0.1930.0430.106
Al₂O₃0.2150.0510.120
SS440C0.1750.0220.072

Table 7: Results of COF testing on the plastic lens.

Linear Wear

Test parameterValue
Load20 N
Test duration20 min
Speed100 rpm
Amplitude10 mm
Total distance40 m
Ball materialZrO₂
Ball diameter6 mm

Table 8: Parameters used for linear wear testing on polycarbonate lens.

The linear test was conducted near the apex of the lens to minimize effects from curvature. From the COF graph, two stages of wear can be observed. At 0-200 revolutions, the two surfaces are adapting to surface of the sample. After 200 revolutions, significant wear begins to occur. Loose particles created from the wear test are now rampant along the surface of the worn area, creating three-body abrasion wear. To accurately calculate wear rate, the volume loss was calculated by profiling the wear track, analytically removing the curvature from the lens, and conducting a volume of a hole study (Figure 18). A total volume of 577,479,379µm³ was lost. The zirconium oxide wore an average of 61.69 ± 6.830µm into the plastic lens.

Linear wear friction graph of the lens against a ZrO2 ball over 2000 revolutions
Fig. 16: Friction graph from linear wear testing.
Polycarbonate lens with a wear track, the 3D view of the track, and the volume-of-a-hole result of 577479379 cubic micrometers
Figs. 17–18: Sample of polycarbonate lens with wear track (left), 3-D view of the wear track (Fig. 17, top right) and volume of a hole analysis conducted on the worn area (Fig. 18, bottom right).
Series of profiles across the wear track with the mean profile, and their primary profile parameters
Fig. 19: Extracted series of profiles (left) and their primary profile parameters (right). Red line indicates the mean profile.
Max COFMin COFAverage COFVolume loss (µm³)Wear rate x 10⁻⁵ (mm³/Nm)
0.4590.0370.33657747937972.185

Table 9: Linear wear testing results.

Close-up of a red traffic light with a ribbed Fresnel lens

Conclusion

Important properties of polycarbonate lens were investigated using NANOVEA’s metrology instruments. The ability to accurately measure and quantify properties of materials is important for material selection and quality control processes.

Profilometry testing included roughness, radius, and thickness measurements. Scratch resistance or scratch hardness testing was conducted on our mechanical tester. The COF and wear rate of the plastic lens was obtained by using the tribometer.

The different types of testing show NANOVEA is able to target a wide variety of specific applications with our instruments. Environmental conditions can also be easily applied with our temperature, humidity, lubrication, and corrosion modules.

References

Kogler, Kent. “Selection of plastics for optical applications.” Advanced materials and processes technology (1999).
Li, Duanjie. “Scratch Hardness Measurement Using Mechanical Tester.” (2014).

Frequently Asked Questions About Polycarbonate Lens Testing

Which lens properties can a 3D profilometer measure?

Radius of curvature, surface roughness and thickness. Here the front side measured 142.1 and 135.5 mm radius in X and Y, the back side 137.0 and 139.2 mm, with Sa of 26.76 nm (front) and 18.16 nm (back).

How is lens thickness measured without contact?

An axial chromatism point sensor puts a focal point on each surface; the refraction between air and the sample is corrected with the index of refraction (1.58 for polycarbonate), and subtracting the two surfaces gives the thickness, about 2.611 mm here.

Why test the scratch hardness of a plastic lens?

The main concern for consumers is how easily polycarbonate lenses scratch. Scratch hardness, measured here per ASTM G171, quantifies the bulk material or the effectiveness of a scratch-resistant coating; this lens gave 420.59 ± 8.69 MPa.

How does polycarbonate compare with metals for scratch hardness?

Earlier NANOVEA tests gave aluminum 0.84, copper 0.52 and steel 3.20 GPa. Although conditions differed, the lens’s scratch resistance appears to be of the same magnitude as copper, a soft, scratch-prone metal.

Which ball material gives the lowest friction on polycarbonate?

In a low-load spiral pin-on-disk test, the average COF ranked rubber 0.734, Al2O3 0.120, ZrO2 0.106, PTFE 0.089 and SS440C 0.072, the lowest.

How is the wear rate of a curved lens measured?

The wear track is profiled, the lens curvature is removed analytically, and a volume-of-a-hole study gives the volume lost. A ZrO2 ball at 20 N removed 577,479,379 µm³, a wear rate of 72.185 x 10⁻⁵ mm³/Nm.

Need to Qualify a Lens or Optical Plastic?